We live in a time of considerable turmoil, both politically and culturally. The news is replete with headlines that only a handful of years ago would have been unimaginable. And our cultural trajectory appears to be unrelentingly “slouching towards Gomorrah”, as Robert Bork perceptively diagnosed in his well-known 2003 book of the same title.[1] The current state of affairs shocks many of us, and it raises the perennial question of how should the church engage with the culture in which we live? And what does the current state of worldly affairs reveal about the current state of the American Church?
Eric Metaxas, a cultural commentator, self-described ecumenical Christian, and eclectic author of over thirty books,[2] provides an answer to this question in his book Letter to the American Church (Salem Books, 2022). His response is based heavily on the research he conducted for his bestselling biography of the WWII era German Lutheran pastor, theologian and anti-Nazi dissident, Dietrich Bonhoeffer.[3]
Metaxas exhorts the American Church to learn from Bonhoeffer’s example and see the obvious future societal calamities on the horizon and to speak fearlessly, in faith, to the governing powers and institutions. Metaxas’ additional admonition is to not repeat the mistakes of the German Lutheran Church, which was too closely aligned with the values of the German State, and had become a “Christless Christianity”. The German Church had also ignored Bonhoeffer’s prophetic warnings to push back against the societal evils, which then resulted in calamity for Germany and the rest of the world.
Metaxas’ view can be summarized as follows.
- The American Church should be like Bonhoeffer in criticizing American culture.
- The American Church should not be like the German Church and ignore Bonhoeffer’s warnings to return to our First Love, and to speak out against the evils in the world.
- The church should repent from its unjustifiable and mistaken withdrawal from the world, return to our First Love, and speak out forcefully, in faith, demonstrating that we actually believe in God.
Pastoral Considerations
While this polarizing topic of cultural engagement can be seen from a number of perspectives—political, cultural, historical, eschatological,[4] and even from the perspective of our individual courage, faith, and obedience (or lack thereof)—what is at stake is nothing less than God’s purposes for his church. Within this context, it is the God-ordained role of the elders of a church to evaluate and discern if the counsel of Metaxas’ book is aligned with what God has divinely revealed for his church at the local level.
“Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood.” (Acts 20:28)
Note that the church is the family that God has “obtained with his own blood.” This is a sobering reminder to those that God has put over his flock of how precious his church is to him, and to the infinite cost that he has expended on purchasing a people for himself.[5] Therefore, one must tread with the utmost humility and care when declaring what God has purposed for his blood-purchased people.
Additionally, Metaxas’ rebukes of the American Church can create in his readers (this reviewer included), an emotional and visceral response of outrage to the perceived failures of the American Church. However, Metaxas’ reproaches can and should be first directed at our individual failures to stand up to the culture, because we are a part of the American Church. In an effort to not attend to our personal guilt and disapproval about our lack of faithful and courageous engagement, we can readily transfer our inwardly focused anger outwardly at the Church, and consequently onto our local church leaders. We can be expecting them to do what we should be doing.
Our response to this question of the church and culture should begin with what our individual responsibilities are, particularly given that we live in a representative republic where we have the inestimable privilege of having a substantial say in our government and its policies. Only then should we give attention to an institutional response. Jesus’ rhetorical question of “Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye?” is painfully applicable to this situation.[6]
Therefore, our (perhaps) justifiably stirred-up anger and emotions and righteous indignation must be tempered with a well-considered and biblical response to the issues facing the church and should not be driven by an emotional or ill-conceived or reckless reaction to the immediacy with which we think we must respond to our cultural situation.
We must always keep in mind that it is to Jesus, who is the head of his Church, that we will all give an account. Therefore, we must endeavor to ensure that we are not futilely expending our time and resources on activities that are contrary to God’s desires.
The answer to the question of the role of the Church in regard to cultural engagement is not primarily about societal or political consequences, or even the future of the “American Church” or of America, it is of cosmological and infinite importance. Ultimately, it is about God’s declared purpose for his church, and therefore about the role of the leaders that God has put in place to shepherd his church, and about the role of each of us in being obedient to God’s call on our lives. These are the primary considerations with which Metaxas’ book will and must be evaluated.
And this is the underlying reason for calling this series “To What End?” All discourses—cultural, apologetic, political, doctrinal, ecclesiological—should be considered through the lens of this question. What are we trying to accomplish with this discourse, and does it align with God’s revealed purposes?
An Evaluation of Metaxas’ Answer
The Role of the Church
The first premise of Metaxas’ answer is based on his understanding of God’s call for the American Church. “We should underscore the idea that the centrality of our nation in the world does not mean that we are intrinsically exceptional, but rather that God has sovereignly chosen us to hold the torch of liberty for all the world, and that the Church is central to our doing this.”[7]
Metaxas’ provides a rejoinder to those who would disagree with this statement.
“If anyone would feel that believing God has chosen the American Church for such a vital role somehow smacks of an egotistical nationalism, they have already bought into the Marxist and globalist lie that America is nothing special – or is probably a force for evil at this point.”[8]
There are two primary problems with these statements.[9]
The first problem is that God’s purpose for the American Church and America is simply an assertion for which biblical or other substantiation is not—nor can it be—provided. It presupposes that Metaxas knows with certainty what God is doing with America and the American Church at this specific moment in history. Humility should be our guide when making pronouncements of what God is doing in his creation and should be confined to the unequivocally clear, timeless, and historically orthodox teachings of Scripture. We must take great care to not equate America and the Church too closely.[10]
The second problem is that the validity of this claim must be evaluated by starting with a biblical definition for the role and purpose of the Church. Even though Metaxas properly raises this question in Chapter One, “What is the Church?”, he doesn’t answer with a Scriptural definition of the church. The best answer this reviewer can ascertain is that the church is truly the church when it is faithfully speaking out against the world. But this doesn’t address who and what the church is, but states what the church does. A correct understanding of the first element (what the church is) is essential to getting the second element correct (what the church then does as a result of what it is).[11]
Because this fundamental premise that God has “sovereignly chosen” America/the American Church for the specific purpose of confronting culture is simply asserted and not substantiated, the resulting prescribed actions may be faulty and should be given very careful consideration.[12]
History as Harbinger
The warnings from the WWII era have validity for us today. We have much to learn from the courageous life and message of Bonhoeffer, who fearlessly spoke out at great risk to his life, and we can learn from the intransigence of the German Church which ignored Bonhoeffer’s warnings about the degradation of its obedience to Christ. The German Church had adopted, implicitly and explicitly—or was silent—regarding the abominable beliefs of the Nazi regime. We see something similar happening today in portions of the American Church as it adopts the world’s value on issues of humanity and sexuality, through militant feminism, LGBTQ issues, transgenderism, and even abortion.
The abandonment of Christ is the underlying issue that led to the silence of the German Church in the face of the evils of the Nazi state, as both Bonhoeffer and Metaxas correctly point out. The call to the Church—then and now—to return to Christ is appropriate and essential.
But this is where Metaxas’ prescription falls short, lacks specificity, and is misguided.
His exhortations for the church to rebuke the world’s values are timelessly relevant to the institutional church and should be heeded, but his remedy is to urge the church to not keep focusing on “Bible studies and sermons”, on “business as usual”, and to not “hide behind the idol of evangelism.” This counsel is misguided. It’s not the activities that should be shunned, it’s the content of these activities that needs to be revivified.
The American Church today (and the German Church of old) are adopting the views of the world because of what is being taught in our Bible studies and sermons, and because of a feckless and “easy believism” evangelistic message. In short, the fullness of the gospel is being neutered and made subservient to the world’s ideals. These disciplines need to be fully saturated with the gospel and it needs to be preached and taught and modeled by the churches and their leadership that the gospel is for every aspect of life. If this is the emphasis, then the church would not adopt the mores of the world.
If those in leadership (and those sitting in the seats) adhered to the admonitions of the Psalmist when it comes to listening to the world or to the Word, these issues plaguing the church would fade into irrelevance.
"May your unfailing love come to me, Lord, your salvation, according to your promise;
then I can answer anyone who taunts me, for I trust in your word.
Never take your word of truth from my mouth, for I have put my hope in your laws.
I will always obey your law, for ever and ever.
I will walk about in freedom, for I have sought out your precepts.
I will speak of your statutes before kings and will not be put to shame,
for I delight in your commands because I love them.
I reach out for your commands, which I love, that I may meditate on your decrees.” (Psalm 119:41-48)
This is the antidote to the issues Metaxas raises. A church focused on Christ will not adopt nor acquiesce to the values or demands of the culture. A church focused on Christ will not align with the state. A church focused on Christ will make disciples that are focused on Christ, and those disciples will transform the world around them, one person at a time, when they are obediently loving God and loving their neighbor as themselves.
Additionally, Metaxas’ call for the church to “return to Christ” seems to be a means to an end. Granted, it is for the eminently noble end of staving off WWII type material atrocities in our time, but this should be considered a result of the church’s adherence to the gospel, not the purpose of the church’s adherence to the gospel, which is to be focused on addressing the underlying cause of the world’s suffering—it’s spiritual suffering.
We have to remember that we don’t fight as the world fights, and therefore, the church’s response to the world must be distinctly Christian in nature, otherwise, the church only becomes another political party fighting for dominance in the public arena of ideas.13
The “American Church”
Metaxas does not define who and what constitutes the “American Church”. It is a sweeping indictment that is leveled without specificity. If Metaxas’ concern is about the churches that have abandoned the gospel, which is clearly the case for some denominations, he should call out those denominations and enumerate the charges against them.
The churches that are leaving those denominations, in some cases after hundreds of years, are suffering the consequences that come from their decision to divide. This distress consists of the internal anguish within their congregations caused by the separation and the knowledge that the onlooking world will use this very public disunity to further damage the cause of Christ. On the other hand, taking a principled stand on these issues—to the point of painful and public separation—is speaking truth to the world by demonstrating that these issues are so important, they are worth the cost of disunity. These churches are exhibiting exactly the kind of gospel-centered fearlessness that Metaxas is accusing them of not possessing and would very likely take exception with Metaxas’ criticism.
Conclusion
This book was challenging to review. It is a case where the individual criticisms pointed at the Church have some validity and caused this reviewer to frequently say “Amen”, but when considered as a cohesive argument, they don’t lead to the prescribed remedies, which unfortunately lean toward being reactionary, not well substantiated, and emotional. While granting that Metaxas’ book is intended to be a polemic against the current state of the Church, the lack of specifics on how the Church is to execute his instructions is also detrimental to his charge, and if he is incorrect in his prescriptions, could lead the Church away from God’s intended purposes.
The Church should be more courageous, it should focus on Christ, it should not become complacent, it should not adopt the world’s values, and yes, it should be an institution that provides relief to the world’s suffering. But how this is accomplished is just as important as what it is trying to accomplish. And this is what will be discussed in more depth in the next series of articles.
Footnotes
[1] Bork, Robert. Slouching Towards Gomorrah. (Harper-Collins. 2010).
[2] Eric Metaxas. (2024, April 11). Home - Eric Metaxas. Eric Metaxas -. https://ericmetaxas.com/
[3] Metaxas, E. (2010). Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy: a Righteous Gentile vs. the Third Reich. (Thomas Nelson. 2011).
[4] Eschatological – the theological doctrine of last things
[5] 1 Corinthians 6:20; 7:23
[6] Matthew 7:1-5
[7] Metaxas, Eric. “Introduction.” Letter to the American Church, Kindle Edition, Salem Books, 2022, p. 8.
[8] Ibid, p. 10.
[9] Ascribing this primary purpose to the church is an anemic ecclesiology (the doctrine of the nature and structure of the church). To be fair, this book is not a treatise on the church, but Metaxas does not include or acknowledge any other purposes for the church. Additionally, the charge that those who disagree with his stated purpose for the church are agreeing with an evil ideology, shuts down conflicting opinions and discussion.
[10] Schreiner, P. (2023, April 26). The good, the bad, and the ugly of Christian nationalism. The Gospel Coalition. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/good-bad-ugly-christian-nationalism/
[11] A biblically rooted understanding of the role and purpose of the church will be covered in subsequent articles.
[12] However, this doesn’t mean that there are no valid reasons or methods for the church to engage the culture. A positive case for the role and manner in which the church engages culture will be addressed in subsequent articles.
[13] 1 Corinthians 1:20-31; 2 Corinthians 10:1-6; Perhaps Colossians 2 (the context is not political, but the principle is the same – don’t submit to the rules of the world).







