To What End - Part 6

Jim Densmore • Executive Pastor/Elder
August 2, 2024

21 Minute Read

The Main Idea of this Article

Jesus’ ongoing mission is to save the world, and it is our primary calling as his disciples to continue that mission. We then live out this mission by being a good citizen in God’s Kingdom and by being a good citizen in the cultures within which God has placed us.

Introduction

In 2008, I was living in California and Proposition 8 was passed. This added an amendment to the state Constitution which provided that "Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California."[63] The day after the election, three lawsuits challenging the proposition were filed with the California Supreme Court. They were ultimately successful in defeating the implementation of the amendment. This meant there were now no limits on what marriage could be or who could get married, opening the door to same sex marriage.[64]

I was outraged. Could I as a Christian let something as morally necessary and biblically based as marriage be redefined in a way that is clearly contrary to God’s design? I can vote of course, but is that enough? But what could I actually do? I was one man with no political connections, background or experience – or money! But won’t society continue to slide into further immorality if Christians don’t take a stand? And if Christians don’t take a stand for something as sacred and God-ordained as the institution of marriage, who will?

However, given the transitory nature of political victories – win today only to see the legislation repealed tomorrow – wouldn’t spending more time on this be a fool’s errand? Besides, the world is passing away, isn’t it? And wouldn’t taking on a political issue of this size impede my ability to follow all of Christ commands? Like love my neighbor, to be fully engaged at church, to spread the gospel, to take care of the widows and the poor? There simply isn’t enough time in a day to do all of this.

Do you struggle with frustration and outrage with what is happening in the world and finding the balance between being a good Christian and being a good citizen? Perhaps you’ve decided to fully engage and be a political and cultural warrior because this is what it means to live out the life of faith that Christ calls us to. Or perhaps you’ve gotten to the place where you no longer concern yourself with the matters of the world, for all the reasons I listed above, and have disengaged from all societal or political activities. Or maybe you’re somewhere in the middle but confused about the best way forward.

In this article, I will provide biblically based answers to these questions that have been with God’s people from the beginning. I will also show how Jesus and the Apostles provide the goal for why we interact with the world, as well as the means for how we interact with the world. I will also show that the Scriptures give us needed guardrails so that we don’t wander from our missional focus.[65]

We’re On A Mission from God

Jesus’ Inauguration of the Mission

Let’s begin by looking at the mission of Jesus, the head of the Church, to understand why we are to interact, engage and be involved with the people of the world.

"For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through him.” (John 3:16-17)[66]

The Father gave the Son a mission - to save the world. Jesus, out of his love for his Father and for the world, inaugurated this mission by taking on the nature of a man and living a sinless life. He then suffered the punishment of the Father for our sins and our behalf by being crucified. He then dies, is buried in a tomb, and raises from the dead three days later. This mission could only be accomplished by Jesus who was fully God and fully man.

This shows us how monumental and eternal this mission is. The Father sacrificed his only begotten Son for this mission. Jesus gave up his heavenly rights (for a time) and laid down and took up his life for this mission. Those who are the beneficiaries of this mission are said to be “bought with the blood of Jesus”.[67] Given who the actors are and what’s at stake – saving the world – there is no greater mission.

The Disciples Role in the Continuation of the Mission

And this same mission is what Jesus’ followers are to be about. When Jesus was preparing his disciples for his crucifixion and ascension, he prays to the Father for them and gives them the charge to continue the mission that he began.

“They are not of the world, just as I am not of the world. Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth. As you sent me into the world, so I have sent them into the world.” (John 17:16-18 Emphasis added)

In the same way that the Father has sent Jesus into the world, Jesus is going to send his disciples into the world. Then, Jesus prays for the next generation of his disciples.

"I do not ask for these only, but also for those who will believe in me through their word, that they may all be one, just as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me.” (John 17:20-21)

Then, after Jesus’ resurrection, he gives his followers his Great Commission.

Then Jesus came to them and said, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age.” (Matt. 28:18-20)

Jesus’ intent is that his mission will continue, first through his contemporary disciples, and then through each successive generation of disciples. If you’re a believer today, it’s because the original disciples obeyed Jesus’ instructions, and the believers after them, and then the ones after them, and then on through the countless generations of believers who have faithfully and obediently continued Jesus’ mission, all the way up to the person who told you about Jesus.

The Church’s Role in the Continuing Mission

It’s the role of the church to enable this mission. For us to make disciples, we have to be equipped as disciples. If we’re not growing as disciples, then how can we obey Christ’s commands to teach others to be disciples?

And he (Jesus) gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, so that we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes. (Eph. 4:11-14)

This is why we are to be engaging with the people of the world. We are commanded to tell people about Jesus and make more followers of Jesus. A good friend of mine says that “We don’t only have to be evangelists, we get to be evangelists”. In other words, it’s a duty but it’s also a privilege that God entrusts us with – to be the ones whose feet bring the Good News![68] And to continue the most important and eternal mission of God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.

This is the guiding star of our engagement with the world. Our interactions with the world must always be in service to the spreading of the gospel, which is the primary mission of individual Christians and of the Church as an organization. This foundational principle of why we engage with the world then informs how we engage with the world, which I will address next.

Being Good Missionaries and Being Good Citizens

Kingdom Citizenship

As I discussed in my previous article, Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount is the touchstone for how to live as a Christian and impact the world around us for the cause of Christ.[69] When Christians live according to the ethics that he taught in this sermon, which were diametrically opposed to the values of the cultural Jew and the Gentiles of his time (and to our culture today), this is how Christians will then “…let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven.” (Matt. 5:16). This is what it means to be “salt and light” – to live by the values of the Kingdom of Heaven which will then reveal the glory of God to the world, and that will have an impact on the world.

This is our primary and eternal citizenship - being in the Kingdom of God. The ethics of this kingdom determine and shape how we behave in the cultures that we live in, which is where our secondary and temporary citizenship lays.

Cultural Citizenship

While Jesus’ very existence and the way in which he lived, taught and conducted his ministry were a threat to both the corrupt Jewish leadership of the time and the Roman empire, Jesus only once spoke explicitly about how to live under Roman law. It was when the Pharisees tried to trap him by asking him if it was lawful for the Jews to pay taxes to Caesar or not.[70] If he affirmed either the Jewish or the Gentiles perspective, he was putting his life in danger from either the Roman authorities or the Jewish crowds and Zealots.[71] But to the amazement of his hostile questioners, Jesus’ response was “Caesar gave you the money you have, so when you’re paying taxes, you’re just giving back to him what he’s already given you. So do that. And then do the same with God – give back to him what he’s already given you.”

Without considering all the nuances of this interaction, the takeaway for us is that if Jesus wanted to disengage from the society in which they lived, or to fight or resist Roman rule, this would have been the opportunity for him to do so. But Jesus is staying on mission. Creating a societal revolt through political revolution would be working contrary to the very mission the Father gave Jesus. Instead, he’s telling the Jews to obey the Roman laws, i.e., be a good citizen.[72]

This theme of being a good citizen as part of the life of a Christian is a theme that we see repeatedly in the Epistles. And it’s what enables Jesus’ mission to continue, regardless of what culture or society someone lives in.

Paul on Being a Good Citizen

In the Apostle’s letters to the newly converted Jewish and Gentile believers, we repeatedly see the writers encouraging and instructing the recipients on how to live within cultures that were hostile to this new religion of “Christianity”. They needed to learn to let go of the cultural baggage they brought with them, and they also had to resist their culture’s enticement to go back to their old ways of life.

As Paul comes to the application portion of the letter he wrote to the Jewish and Gentile believers in Rome, he concludes the first eleven chapters with this well-known instruction – “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.” (Rom. 12:2). This is a reminder and an admonition to not live like the world does, but to reframe all of our thinking by what it means to live in the Kingdom of God.

Continuing, he explains to them what this looks like, and instructs them to “repay no one evil for evil” (12:17a), “do what is honorable in the sight of all” (12:17b), “live peaceably with all” (12:18), “never avenge yourselves” (12:19), “overcome evil with good” (12:21).

And then in Chapter 13, where Paul directly addresses the nature of the relationship between the believers and the Roman state, we see Paul teach “let every person by subject to the governing authorities” (13:1), “do what is good” (13:3b), “be in subjection” (13:5), and “pay to all what is owed to them” (13:7a), which includes taxes, revenue, respect and honor. (13:7b)

These verses describe how they are to exist as dual citizens – Chapter 12 is how they are to treat people according to their primary citizenship, and the verses in Chapter 13 describe how they are to relate to the governing authorities, which is their secondary citizenship, but this is still governed by their primary citizenship.

Peter on Being a Good Citizen

In Peter’s first letter to the churches in Asia Minor, he is encouraging them to remain faithful and endure the persecution they are and will be suffering for being Christ followers, by living exemplary lives.

Live such good lives among the pagans that, though they accuse you of doing wrong, they may see your good deeds and glorify God on the day he visits us. Submit yourselves for the Lord's sake to every human authority: whether to the emperor, as the supreme authority, or to governors, who are sent by him to punish those who do wrong and to commend those who do right. For it is God's will that by doing good you should silence the ignorant talk of foolish people. Live as free people, but do not use your freedom as a cover-up for evil; live as God's slaves. Show proper respect to everyone, love the family of believers, fear God, honor the emperor. (1 Peter 2:12-17)

Why would these believers be accused of doing wrong by their fellow citizens? Because by not living according to the religious norms of their day, which would have been polytheistic and based on idol worship, these “one-God” Christians would be seen as atheists, disrupters and usurpers. We see this throughout the book of Acts, when Paul and his cohorts come preaching the gospel and it creates enormous cultural, political, religious and economic turmoil, even though Paul never advocates for any of these things to happen.

Peter’s instruction to these believers is not to live like the Gentiles do, but to live lives of the kingdom ethic and to be good citizens. This will demonstrate that they are in fact, not a threat in the way their fellow citizens perceive, but will show them to be kind, loving, fellow citizens who want to contribute to the common good of their neighbors. By doing this, they will be “salt and light” and will attract people to their Savior.

This is how we engage with the world in the name of Christ – by loving God (our primary citizenship and where we derive our Kingdom values), and then by loving our neighbor (which is our secondary citizenship and where we live out our Kingdom values).

The same friend I quoted previously also provides this helpful counsel: “Be the kind of neighbor that if you were to leave your neighborhood, you’d be missed.”

How to Stay on Mission

Mission Guardrails

In 1 Corinthians 7, we see Paul continually instruct these church members about how to live as Christians in a culture that is hostile to them, and that is continually working to draw them back into its ways. But Paul’s instructions about marriage, life situations, circumcision, indentured servitude, and business dealings follow an approach of “Yes, care about these things, but not too much.” This is because “…the time is short.” (1 Cor. 7: 29b) and “For this world in its present form is passing away.” (1 Cor. 7:31b)

When we are tempted by the ongoing and never-ending turmoil in the world and culture that surrounds us, to make cultural or political or societal transformation our primary mission, we need to remember and submit to the Leader of our true mission, and to his instructions and commands as to why and how we are to continue his eternal mission, and that we are to care about the things of the world, but not too much. These are the guardrails the Scriptures provide us to prevent us from careening off the road of our true mission.

Avenues of Engagement

The answer to the questions about if we are to be politically active or to not be politically active, is that we are called to be good Christians and to be good citizens, in keeping with the dual nature of our citizenship. The former informs the latter. So, considering this, how could I have responded to the Proposition 8 situation?

For me to have taken on Proposition 8 at the level I was thinking (which was not rational, it was an emotional reaction), was not realistic, as I didn’t have any of the necessary giftings or skill sets. But I could have supported those who were fighting it with signatures, or finances, or raising awareness about it, or writing articles about it for our church. There are many avenues available because as “Western” Christians we enjoy privileges that most of God’s people have never had, which includes having the right to participate in and influence our government and our laws. We should avail ourselves of every opportunity to do good, which includes political engagement, at whatever level we can be effective. For some, it will be voting. For others, it will be to actively campaign for a politician or an issue. And for some, it may mean being a politician. Whichever avenue one takes to engage is part of being a good dual citizen and is completely in alignment with God’s call on his people.

The choice to be a cultural warrior and to fight against societal evils to such an extent that there is no room for the gospel is to stray from the goal of God’s mission. The question we must ask is how much time are we spending on societal transformation (which is temporary and passing away) and how much time are we spending on making disciples (which is of eternal value)?

The choice to completely disengage from the culture around us and not participate in creating a good society with our fellow citizens is to stray from the how of God’s mission. When we were saved, God could have taken us to heaven immediately. But he leaves us all here so that we can be confirmed into the image of God anew, but also so that we can tell other people about his Son - which also helps us become like his Son. By being a good citizen, in whatever form this takes, we are using the common cultural touchstones we have with our neighbors to engage with them. And living our kingdom values demonstrates God’s glory to them and invites them to become citizens in a new and better and ever-lasting Kingdom.

It’s About People Not Issues

The overturning of “Roe v. Wade” is emphatically a win for righteousness and for fighting evil. Since this is now being taken up by the states for their determination of what the laws should be around abortion, and since some states will be restrictive, the result will be less abortions. This is a net good.

However, in the same way that pro-choice advocates saw their legislative win that lasted fifty years disappear overnight, pro-life advocates may experience the same thing, if a national law is eventually codified permitting abortions. Political victories are fleeting. If our only goal as Christians is the ending of abortion, we will probably never achieve total victory, and the victories we do achieve will almost certainly be temporary.

But if our goal in fighting abortion is about people and not just the issue itself, then we can see eternal victories. We must remember that the young women and ladies that are considering this option need the truth of Christ that teaches about the eternal value of all human life, and that each person carries with them the imago Dei – the image of God. For those that have had abortions, they need the forgiveness of Jesus. For those that are teaching and advocating and putting abortion into law (and even celebrating it!), they need to know about the righteousness of God and that they will be held accountable for these actions. And they need to know about how these sins can be forgiven through the blood of Christ. And we can also help through volunteering or financially supporting Community Pregnancy Centers. They help to prevent women from having an abortion, as well as providing care for those who have their baby. They also provide post-abortive care.

When speaking at a Board of Supervisor meetings, or at the School board, we need to ensure that Christ and the gospel are proclaimed as the basis for our objections (or affirmations) of an issue.

We must make our political activities uniquely Christian and in service to the gospel. This is how we avoid becoming just another special interest group clamoring for a win in the colosseums of political battles. We don’t want the issue to become “the thing” instead of Christ saving people.

Rosaria Butterfield, who was a militant, Lesbian, feminist professor, who became a Christian, teaches that she didn’t need laws against homosexuality, or to become a heterosexual, she needed Christ.[73]

Societal Transformation – A Result not a Goal

John 3:16 doesn’t say that Jesus came “to transform the world”, it says he came “to save the world.” When we stay on the mission that we’ve been entrusted with, we will see eternal results through the people God saves through our participation, and as we live out our salvation, we will hopefully see the people around us transformed, as they become fully devoted followers of Christ, which will translate into culture and societal transformation.[74]

The most powerful “political” activity we can engage in for the good of our families, our workplace, our schools, our neighborhoods, our towns, our cities, our counties, our states, our nation and the world, is to love God with all our heart, soul, mind and strength, and to love our neighbor as ourselves. (Matt. 22:34-40)

Footnotes

[63] Proposition 8. (n.d.). California Courts. https://www.courts.ca.gov/6465.htm

[64] https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/NR29-09.PDF. Ironically, the amendment is still in the California Constitution, it’s just not enforced.

[65] I am indebted to several authors and resources for this article. The main source is Thompson, J. W. (2023). Christ and Culture in the New Testament. Wipf and Stock Publishers. This material provides a detailed exploration of the themes of citizenship throughout the New Testament.

[66] All Scripture references are English Standard Version – ESV – unless otherwise noted.

[67] Acts 20:28

[68] Isaiah 52:7; Nahum 1:15; Romans 10:15; Ephesians 6:15

[69] Densmore, James. “Christian Engagement with the World.” Keeping in Touch, 1 August 2024. Please contact the church office for a copy.

[70] Matt. 22:15-22; Mark 12:13-17; Luke 20:19-26

[71] If he answered that it was lawful, then he would be demonstrating loyalty to the Romans, which would have put his life in danger from the crowds and Zealots. If he said that it is not lawful, then because of previous events related to the Roman imposition of taxes, it could have started a rebellion from the Jews against the Romans, for which the Romans would punish Jesus for inciting. Jesus’ answer amazes them, and they don’t bring this up again!

[72] Even though Jesus was not talking to his disciples, this event does demonstrate Jesus’ thoughts on living within a hostile culture.

[73] Butterfield, R. C. (2014). The Secret Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert: An English Professor’s Journey into Christian Faith.

[74] The first two to three hundred years of Christianity saw the Roman empire transformed by Christians, who had no say in their culture or their laws or their government, but who only lived out their faith.

Up Next
From this Author: Jim Densmore
August 2, 2024 • 21 Minute Read
To What End - Part 6
The Main Idea of this Article Jesus’ ongoing mission is to save the world, and it is our primary calling as his disciples to continue that mission. We then live out this mission by being a good citizen in God’s Kingdom and by being a good citizen in the cultures within which God has placed us. Introduction In 2008, I was living in California and Proposition 8 was passed. This added an amendment to the state Constitution which provided that "Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California."[63] The day after the election, three lawsuits challenging the proposition were filed with the California Supreme Court. They were ultimately successful in defeating the implementation of the amendment. This meant there were now no limits on what marriage could be or who could get married, opening the door to same sex marriage.[64] I was outraged. Could I as a Christian let something as morally necessary and biblically based as marriage be redefined in a way that is clearly contrary to God’s design? I can vote of course, but is that enough? But what could I actually do? I was one man with no political connections, background or experience – or money! But won’t society continue to slide into further immorality if Christians don’t take a stand? And if Christians don’t take a stand for something as sacred and God-ordained as the institution of marriage, who will? However, given the transitory nature of political victories – win today only to see the legislation repealed tomorrow – wouldn’t spending more time on this be a fool’s errand? Besides, the world is passing away, isn’t it? And wouldn’t taking on a political issue of this size impede my ability to follow all of Christ commands? Like love my neighbor, to be fully engaged at church, to spread the gospel, to take care of the widows and the poor? There simply isn’t enough time in a day to do all of this. Do you struggle with frustration and outrage with what is happening in the world and finding the balance between being a good Christian and being a good citizen? Perhaps you’ve decided to fully engage and be a political and cultural warrior because this is what it means to live out the life of faith that Christ calls us to. Or perhaps you’ve gotten to the place where you no longer concern yourself with the matters of the world, for all the reasons I listed above, and have disengaged from all societal or political activities. Or maybe you’re somewhere in the middle but confused about the best way forward. In this article, I will provide biblically based answers to these questions that have been with God’s people from the beginning. I will also show how Jesus and the Apostles provide the goal for why we interact with the world, as well as the means for how we interact with the world. I will also show that the Scriptures give us needed guardrails so that we don’t wander from our missional focus.[65] We’re On A Mission from God Jesus’ Inauguration of the Mission Let’s begin by looking at the mission of Jesus, the head of the Church, to understand why we are to interact, engage and be involved with the people of the world. "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through him.” (John 3:16-17)[66] The Father gave the Son a mission - to save the world. Jesus, out of his love for his Father and for the world, inaugurated this mission by taking on the nature of a man and living a sinless life. He then suffered the punishment of the Father for our sins and our behalf by being crucified. He then dies, is buried in a tomb, and raises from the dead three days later. This mission could only be accomplished by Jesus who was fully God and fully man. This shows us how monumental and eternal this mission is. The Father sacrificed his only begotten Son for this mission. Jesus gave up his heavenly rights (for a time) and laid down and took up his life for this mission. Those who are the beneficiaries of this mission are said to be “bought with the blood of Jesus”.[67] Given who the actors are and what’s at stake – saving the world – there is no greater mission. The Disciples Role in the Continuation of the Mission And this same mission is what Jesus’ followers are to be about. When Jesus was preparing his disciples for his crucifixion and ascension, he prays to the Father for them and gives them the charge to continue the mission that he began. “They are not of the world, just as I am not of the world. Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth. As you sent me into the world, so I have sent them into the world.” (John 17:16-18 Emphasis added) In the same way that the Father has sent Jesus into the world, Jesus is going to send his disciples into the world. Then, Jesus prays for the next generation of his disciples. "I do not ask for these only, but also for those who will believe in me through their word, that they may all be one, just as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me.” (John 17:20-21) Then, after Jesus’ resurrection, he gives his followers his Great Commission. Then Jesus came to them and said, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age.” (Matt. 28:18-20) Jesus’ intent is that his mission will continue, first through his contemporary disciples, and then through each successive generation of disciples. If you’re a believer today, it’s because the original disciples obeyed Jesus’ instructions, and the believers after them, and then the ones after them, and then on through the countless generations of believers who have faithfully and obediently continued Jesus’ mission, all the way up to the person who told you about Jesus. The Church’s Role in the Continuing Mission It’s the role of the church to enable this mission. For us to make disciples, we have to be equipped as disciples. If we’re not growing as disciples, then how can we obey Christ’s commands to teach others to be disciples? And he (Jesus) gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, so that we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes. (Eph. 4:11-14) This is why we are to be engaging with the people of the world. We are commanded to tell people about Jesus and make more followers of Jesus. A good friend of mine says that “We don’t only have to be evangelists, we get to be evangelists”. In other words, it’s a duty but it’s also a privilege that God entrusts us with – to be the ones whose feet bring the Good News![68] And to continue the most important and eternal mission of God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. This is the guiding star of our engagement with the world. Our interactions with the world must always be in service to the spreading of the gospel, which is the primary mission of individual Christians and of the Church as an organization. This foundational principle of why we engage with the world then informs how we engage with the world, which I will address next. Being Good Missionaries and Being Good Citizens Kingdom Citizenship As I discussed in my previous article, Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount is the touchstone for how to live as a Christian and impact the world around us for the cause of Christ.[69] When Christians live according to the ethics that he taught in this sermon, which were diametrically opposed to the values of the cultural Jew and the Gentiles of his time (and to our culture today), this is how Christians will then “…let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven.” (Matt. 5:16). This is what it means to be “salt and light” – to live by the values of the Kingdom of Heaven which will then reveal the glory of God to the world, and that will have an impact on the world. This is our primary and eternal citizenship - being in the Kingdom of God. The ethics of this kingdom determine and shape how we behave in the cultures that we live in, which is where our secondary and temporary citizenship lays. Cultural Citizenship While Jesus’ very existence and the way in which he lived, taught and conducted his ministry were a threat to both the corrupt Jewish leadership of the time and the Roman empire, Jesus only once spoke explicitly about how to live under Roman law. It was when the Pharisees tried to trap him by asking him if it was lawful for the Jews to pay taxes to Caesar or not.[70] If he affirmed either the Jewish or the Gentiles perspective, he was putting his life in danger from either the Roman authorities or the Jewish crowds and Zealots.[71] But to the amazement of his hostile questioners, Jesus’ response was “Caesar gave you the money you have, so when you’re paying taxes, you’re just giving back to him what he’s already given you. So do that. And then do the same with God – give back to him what he’s already given you.” Without considering all the nuances of this interaction, the takeaway for us is that if Jesus wanted to disengage from the society in which they lived, or to fight or resist Roman rule, this would have been the opportunity for him to do so. But Jesus is staying on mission. Creating a societal revolt through political revolution would be working contrary to the very mission the Father gave Jesus. Instead, he’s telling the Jews to obey the Roman laws, i.e., be a good citizen.[72] This theme of being a good citizen as part of the life of a Christian is a theme that we see repeatedly in the Epistles. And it’s what enables Jesus’ mission to continue, regardless of what culture or society someone lives in. Paul on Being a Good Citizen In the Apostle’s letters to the newly converted Jewish and Gentile believers, we repeatedly see the writers encouraging and instructing the recipients on how to live within cultures that were hostile to this new religion of “Christianity”. They needed to learn to let go of the cultural baggage they brought with them, and they also had to resist their culture’s enticement to go back to their old ways of life. As Paul comes to the application portion of the letter he wrote to the Jewish and Gentile believers in Rome, he concludes the first eleven chapters with this well-known instruction – “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.” (Rom. 12:2). This is a reminder and an admonition to not live like the world does, but to reframe all of our thinking by what it means to live in the Kingdom of God. Continuing, he explains to them what this looks like, and instructs them to “repay no one evil for evil” (12:17a), “do what is honorable in the sight of all” (12:17b), “live peaceably with all” (12:18), “never avenge yourselves” (12:19), “overcome evil with good” (12:21). And then in Chapter 13, where Paul directly addresses the nature of the relationship between the believers and the Roman state, we see Paul teach “let every person by subject to the governing authorities” (13:1), “do what is good” (13:3b), “be in subjection” (13:5), and “pay to all what is owed to them” (13:7a), which includes taxes, revenue, respect and honor. (13:7b) These verses describe how they are to exist as dual citizens – Chapter 12 is how they are to treat people according to their primary citizenship, and the verses in Chapter 13 describe how they are to relate to the governing authorities, which is their secondary citizenship, but this is still governed by their primary citizenship. Peter on Being a Good Citizen In Peter’s first letter to the churches in Asia Minor, he is encouraging them to remain faithful and endure the persecution they are and will be suffering for being Christ followers, by living exemplary lives. Live such good lives among the pagans that, though they accuse you of doing wrong, they may see your good deeds and glorify God on the day he visits us. Submit yourselves for the Lord's sake to every human authority: whether to the emperor, as the supreme authority, or to governors, who are sent by him to punish those who do wrong and to commend those who do right. For it is God's will that by doing good you should silence the ignorant talk of foolish people. Live as free people, but do not use your freedom as a cover-up for evil; live as God's slaves. Show proper respect to everyone, love the family of believers, fear God, honor the emperor. (1 Peter 2:12-17) Why would these believers be accused of doing wrong by their fellow citizens? Because by not living according to the religious norms of their day, which would have been polytheistic and based on idol worship, these “one-God” Christians would be seen as atheists, disrupters and usurpers. We see this throughout the book of Acts, when Paul and his cohorts come preaching the gospel and it creates enormous cultural, political, religious and economic turmoil, even though Paul never advocates for any of these things to happen. Peter’s instruction to these believers is not to live like the Gentiles do, but to live lives of the kingdom ethic and to be good citizens. This will demonstrate that they are in fact, not a threat in the way their fellow citizens perceive, but will show them to be kind, loving, fellow citizens who want to contribute to the common good of their neighbors. By doing this, they will be “salt and light” and will attract people to their Savior. This is how we engage with the world in the name of Christ – by loving God (our primary citizenship and where we derive our Kingdom values), and then by loving our neighbor (which is our secondary citizenship and where we live out our Kingdom values). The same friend I quoted previously also provides this helpful counsel: “Be the kind of neighbor that if you were to leave your neighborhood, you’d be missed.” How to Stay on Mission Mission Guardrails In 1 Corinthians 7, we see Paul continually instruct these church members about how to live as Christians in a culture that is hostile to them, and that is continually working to draw them back into its ways. But Paul’s instructions about marriage, life situations, circumcision, indentured servitude, and business dealings follow an approach of “Yes, care about these things, but not too much.” This is because “…the time is short.” (1 Cor. 7: 29b) and “For this world in its present form is passing away.” (1 Cor. 7:31b) When we are tempted by the ongoing and never-ending turmoil in the world and culture that surrounds us, to make cultural or political or societal transformation our primary mission, we need to remember and submit to the Leader of our true mission, and to his instructions and commands as to why and how we are to continue his eternal mission, and that we are to care about the things of the world, but not too much. These are the guardrails the Scriptures provide us to prevent us from careening off the road of our true mission. Avenues of Engagement The answer to the questions about if we are to be politically active or to not be politically active, is that we are called to be good Christians and to be good citizens, in keeping with the dual nature of our citizenship. The former informs the latter. So, considering this, how could I have responded to the Proposition 8 situation? For me to have taken on Proposition 8 at the level I was thinking (which was not rational, it was an emotional reaction), was not realistic, as I didn’t have any of the necessary giftings or skill sets. But I could have supported those who were fighting it with signatures, or finances, or raising awareness about it, or writing articles about it for our church. There are many avenues available because as “Western” Christians we enjoy privileges that most of God’s people have never had, which includes having the right to participate in and influence our government and our laws. We should avail ourselves of every opportunity to do good, which includes political engagement, at whatever level we can be effective. For some, it will be voting. For others, it will be to actively campaign for a politician or an issue. And for some, it may mean being a politician. Whichever avenue one takes to engage is part of being a good dual citizen and is completely in alignment with God’s call on his people. The choice to be a cultural warrior and to fight against societal evils to such an extent that there is no room for the gospel is to stray from the goal of God’s mission. The question we must ask is how much time are we spending on societal transformation (which is temporary and passing away) and how much time are we spending on making disciples (which is of eternal value)? The choice to completely disengage from the culture around us and not participate in creating a good society with our fellow citizens is to stray from the how of God’s mission. When we were saved, God could have taken us to heaven immediately. But he leaves us all here so that we can be confirmed into the image of God anew, but also so that we can tell other people about his Son - which also helps us become like his Son. By being a good citizen, in whatever form this takes, we are using the common cultural touchstones we have with our neighbors to engage with them. And living our kingdom values demonstrates God’s glory to them and invites them to become citizens in a new and better and ever-lasting Kingdom. It’s About People Not Issues The overturning of “Roe v. Wade” is emphatically a win for righteousness and for fighting evil. Since this is now being taken up by the states for their determination of what the laws should be around abortion, and since some states will be restrictive, the result will be less abortions. This is a net good. However, in the same way that pro-choice advocates saw their legislative win that lasted fifty years disappear overnight, pro-life advocates may experience the same thing, if a national law is eventually codified permitting abortions. Political victories are fleeting. If our only goal as Christians is the ending of abortion, we will probably never achieve total victory, and the victories we do achieve will almost certainly be temporary. But if our goal in fighting abortion is about people and not just the issue itself, then we can see eternal victories. We must remember that the young women and ladies that are considering this option need the truth of Christ that teaches about the eternal value of all human life, and that each person carries with them the imago Dei – the image of God. For those that have had abortions, they need the forgiveness of Jesus. For those that are teaching and advocating and putting abortion into law (and even celebrating it!), they need to know about the righteousness of God and that they will be held accountable for these actions. And they need to know about how these sins can be forgiven through the blood of Christ. And we can also help through volunteering or financially supporting Community Pregnancy Centers. They help to prevent women from having an abortion, as well as providing care for those who have their baby. They also provide post-abortive care. When speaking at a Board of Supervisor meetings, or at the School board, we need to ensure that Christ and the gospel are proclaimed as the basis for our objections (or affirmations) of an issue. We must make our political activities uniquely Christian and in service to the gospel. This is how we avoid becoming just another special interest group clamoring for a win in the colosseums of political battles. We don’t want the issue to become “the thing” instead of Christ saving people. Rosaria Butterfield, who was a militant, Lesbian, feminist professor, who became a Christian, teaches that she didn’t need laws against homosexuality, or to become a heterosexual, she needed Christ.[73] Societal Transformation – A Result not a Goal John 3:16 doesn’t say that Jesus came “to transform the world”, it says he came “to save the world.” When we stay on the mission that we’ve been entrusted with, we will see eternal results through the people God saves through our participation, and as we live out our salvation, we will hopefully see the people around us transformed, as they become fully devoted followers of Christ, which will translate into culture and societal transformation.[74] The most powerful “political” activity we can engage in for the good of our families, our workplace, our schools, our neighborhoods, our towns, our cities, our counties, our states, our nation and the world, is to love God with all our heart, soul, mind and strength, and to love our neighbor as ourselves. (Matt. 22:34-40)Download this articleDownload the 6 article series Footnotes [63] Proposition 8. (n.d.). California Courts. https://www.courts.ca.gov/6465.htm [64] https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/NR29-09.PDF. Ironically, the amendment is still in the California Constitution, it’s just not enforced. [65] I am indebted to several authors and resources for this article. The main source is Thompson, J. W. (2023). Christ and Culture in the New Testament. Wipf and Stock Publishers. This material provides a detailed exploration of the themes of citizenship throughout the New Testament. [66] All Scripture references are English Standard Version – ESV – unless otherwise noted. [67] Acts 20:28 [68] Isaiah 52:7; Nahum 1:15; Romans 10:15; Ephesians 6:15 [69] Densmore, James. “Christian Engagement with the World.” Keeping in Touch, 1 August 2024. Please contact the church office for a copy. [70] Matt. 22:15-22; Mark 12:13-17; Luke 20:19-26 [71] If he answered that it was lawful, then he would be demonstrating loyalty to the Romans, which would have put his life in danger from the crowds and Zealots. If he said that it is not lawful, then because of previous events related to the Roman imposition of taxes, it could have started a rebellion from the Jews against the Romans, for which the Romans would punish Jesus for inciting. Jesus’ answer amazes them, and they don’t bring this up again! [72] Even though Jesus was not talking to his disciples, this event does demonstrate Jesus’ thoughts on living within a hostile culture. [73] Butterfield, R. C. (2014). The Secret Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert: An English Professor’s Journey into Christian Faith. [74] The first two to three hundred years of Christianity saw the Roman empire transformed by Christians, who had no say in their culture or their laws or their government, but who only lived out their faith.
July 14, 2024 • 20 Minute Read
To What End - Part 4
The Main Idea of this Article Based on the ways in which Jesus and Paul lived, and centered on what they taught, Christians are to engage with the people in the world through shared cultural touchpoints, while shunning the ways of the world. Introduction How should we as Christians participate, and to what degree, and in what manner, with the world and the culture around us? As I have explored this question, I have found an enormous variety of answers, but the two responses that appear most frequently can be summarized as follows: 1) We should separate from the world and limit our participation to just what is necessary to live in the world, and our engagement should be focused on evangelism. This is because we are pilgrims passing through a world that is passing away, and we are to avoid getting involved in earthly affairs.[34] 2) We should intentionally strive to change the world by being cultural warriors, and spearhead cultural and political movements, transforming the culture around us. The well-known quote from Kuyper is how this view is expressed by some: “There is not a square inch in the whole domain of our human existence over which Christ, who is sovereign over all, does not cry: ‘Mine!’”[35] Perhaps you identify with one of these responses more than the other, or perhaps your perspective is somewhere in-between. In this article, building on the biblical foundation laid in my previous article concerning the nature, mission and work of the Church and the government,[36] I will address the first response and argue that while Christians are not to live according to the world’s ethics, this does not mean that we are to withdraw from every aspect of the world. I will also contend that significant engagement with the world and the cultures we live within, is a necessary element of being a Christian, and is modeled and taught in the New Testament. I will address the second response in the next article. Definitions Before proceeding, it will be helpful to define “world” and “culture”. “World” - The Inhabitants of the Planet The true light, which gives light to everyone, was coming into the world. (John 1:10 ESV) For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through him. (John 3:16-17) The usage of “world” here speaks to the inhabitants—the people—who live on our planet. In this sense, we know we are to engage and participate and love the world because of the Incarnation—Jesus leaving heaven, coming to this world, being found in human form, and dying on a cross for the world.[37] “World” – Its Ways Do not love the world or the things in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him. For all that is in the world—the desires of the flesh and the desires of the eyes and pride of life—is not from the Father but is from the world. And the world is passing away along with its desires, but whoever does the will of God abides forever. (1 John 2:15-17) I appeal to you therefore, brothers, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your spiritual worship. Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect. (Romans 12:1-2) This usage of “world’ is speaking to “the whole circle of earthly goods, endowments, riches, advantages, pleasures, etc. which, although hollow and frail and fleeting, stir desire, seduce from God and are obstacles to the cause of Christ.38 Or, as John himself defines it for us— “the desires of the flesh and the desires of the eyes and pride of life”. In this sense, we are clearly meant to “disengage” or “withdraw” from the ways of the world. Culture The New Testament does not have a word for culture, but the idea is found throughout the Gospels and the Epistles. I’m using it to mean the shared beliefs, behaviors, values, typical practices, and goals of a group of people.[39] When I speak of engagement with the world, I am referring to the people that God has put into our lives, and not the worldly ways of the society around us, which we are to avoid. And we are to do this through the shared values, typical practices and goals of the unique cultural setting within which God has placed us. Cultural Engagement as Modeled and Taught by Jesus and Paul Let’s survey relevant New Testament passages to see how Jesus and Paul lived with the world around them, along what they taught about cultural engagement. Jesus’ Way of Life Early in Jesus’ ministry, he is teaching in his hometown synagogue in Nazareth, and the people who heard him couldn’t believe someone like Jesus could be teaching such astonishing things, because he was just a common carpenter40 and came from a typical and unremarkable family.[41] By being seen as a “commoner”, it means that Jesus and his family were not living apart from their culture, but as full participants within their community. Their way of life was the same as that of their neighbors. This would also include living within the restrictions of the Roman Empire. By being a carpenter or artisan, Jesus would have had relationships with other craftsman, he would have been engaged in commerce, buying supplies and selling his creations, and getting paid for his work. He would have to be familiar with the styles of the day and what was popular with the people. Jesus would have also paid taxes (and he taught others to pay taxes).[42] There is an argument to make that Jesus also interacted with Romans in the building trade, given that the largest Roman city in Galilee (Sephoris) was an hour away from Nazareth.[43] We know he was fully versed in all the ways of his people because his teachings were steeped in cultural references – shepherding, vineyards, weddings, fishing, gardening. And his Parables were convicting and polarizing because he well knew the religious traditions and practices of his people, so he understood precisely where and how to indict the Jewish leaders for their hypocrisy and love of power. Jesus was continually accused of associating with unclean people, with whom he regularly shared meals.[44] He would have eaten the same food, drank the same drinks, and respected the same culinary customs of his people. As a guest at a wedding, when prompted by his mother, Jesus performs his first miracle and provides “the fine wine” so that the party could continue! This is not a man who has separated from his culture.[45] A Roman Centurion asked Jesus to heal his servant and insisted that Jesus doesn’t need to physically come to his home to do it, because he knew that Jesus had the authority and power to do it from where Jesus was standing.[46] If Jesus had only been focusing on his personal holiness and separating from the world and the unclean Gentiles, the Centurion wouldn’t have known who Jesus was.[47] Because Jesus was so much a part of his culture and because he was a “commoner” who lived, worked, and celebrated with his people, it gave him insight and credibility, and it equipped him to know how best to evangelize because of the numerous and common touch points he shared. If he lived separately from his people, or the larger world around him, he would not have been able to have the ministry that he did. Jesus’ Teachings - The Sermon on the Mount ‘You are the salt of the earth, but if salt has lost its taste, how shall its saltiness be restored? It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and trampled under people’s feet. ‘You are the light of the world. A city set on a hill cannot be hidden. Nor do people light a lamp and put it under a basket, but on a stand, and it gives light to all in the house. In the same way, let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven.’ (Matt. 5:13-16) This is a passage that is oft cited by those who believe Christians are mandated to transform culture. Their conclusion is that being “salt and light” means that Christians, as a priority of the Christian life, are to be working in their communities and the public arena, shaping and molding culture and laws and governments into Christ-honoring institutions. But notice that vv. 13-16 come after Jesus has first taught the Beatitudes in vv. 1-12. I believe that the Beatitudes are Jesus teaching a new ethic for people who will be citizens in a new kingdom that he has inaugurated at his First Coming and will be consummated at his Second Coming. This new kingdom’s ethic is based on being poor in spirit, mourning, meekness, hungering for righteousness, showing mercy, being pure of heart, peacemaking, and being persecuted for righteousness. This is in direct contrast and contradiction to the condition of much of Jewish culture, not to mention the cultural norms of the Roman Empire. Therefore, cultural engagement is assumed. Jesus is describing a new way of living that is to be done in such a way, that those living with and around these new citizens, will witness a way of life they haven’t seen before, and attribute it to God. If these new kingdom citizens pull away from and separate themselves from their cultures, their lamp of good works will be put under a basket, which is what Jesus has explicitly instructed them not to do. But the Beatitudes speak first and foremost to the heart condition of these new citizens. When they are living with these new kinds of hearts, they can fulfill the rest of the Sermon’s instructions, which speak to how they are to treat each other in personal relationships. Transformation of the heart, which then transforms personal relationships, is of first importance to Jesus. If Jesus’ followers live out these teachings, it will inevitably result in cultural transformation, but the impact on culture is from the ground up and not from the top down, nor is it the point of the Sermon.[48] Paul’s Way of Life Paul was a tentmaker.[49] Everything that was said about Jesus’ engagement with his culture because of his artisan’s profession can be said about Paul. In the same way in which Jesus evangelized within the backdrop of Jewish culture, Paul’s intimate knowledge of Jewish religious culture and the ways of the Jewish leadership equipped him to be a powerful evangelist, given that he had reached its religious pinnacles.[50] When Paul comes to Athens and sees that the city is full of idols his “spirit was provoked within him” and he arranges to teach the Epicurean and Stoic philosophers on the Areopagus about Jesus.[51] Paul is so familiar with their teachings that he quotes their philosophers back to them— “for ‘In him we live and move and have our being’; as even some of your own poets have said, ‘For we are indeed his offspring.’” (Acts 17:28) This would require Paul to have significant prior knowledge of the sophisticated philosophies and literature of the Greeks. He also knew Roman law.[52] He knew how to engage in public discourse—a large part of both the Jewish and Gentile cultures.[53] Paul used his freedom in Christ to effectively evangelize Jew and Gentile. For though I am free from all, I have made myself a servant to all, that I might win more of them. (1 Cor. 9:19)54 We don’t know all the specifics of Paul’s evangelistic efforts, but clearly, he’s not separating and protecting himself from the cultures of the people he’s evangelizing—he’s intentionally entering and engaging with those cultures so that he can more effectively evangelize, even to the point of becoming like them. Paul’s Teachings Paul taught the Christians in the Gentile cities of Ephesus and Thessalonica to work with their own hands—which means engaging and participating with all the related people and areas of their cultures, as Jesus and Paul would have.[55] In Colossians 4:5, Paul instructs the believers to “Walk in wisdom toward outsiders, making the best use of the time.” In 1 Thessalonians 4:10b-12, Paul urges his brothers to “…excel more and more and to aspire to live quietly, to attend to your own matters, and to work with your own hands, as we instructed you. Then you will behave properly toward outsiders, without being dependent on anyone.” And then in 1 Timothy 3:7, when giving qualifications for elders (overseers), he says, “Moreover, he must be well thought of by outsiders, so that he may not fall into disgrace, into a snare of the devil.” Each of these instructions assume cultural engagement and provide clear guidelines for how Christians are to live within cultures that are not Christian—wisely, quietly, and being well thought of. By living this way, the Christians were demonstrating that they did not consider themselves better than those around them, because they lived within the norms of their neighbors and the cultures of their times. This is a reminder to them that they are minority groups that need to be conscious of their reputations. Because God “wants all people to be saved” (1 Tim 2:4), the church does not retreat from the world but declares the Christian message— “the mystery of godliness” (3:16)—and lives in a way that is appropriate to it (cf. Titus 2:1). Good behavior will thus make the faith attractive to outsiders (Titus 2:10) and ensure that others do not slander believers (cf. 1 Tim 5:14; 6:1; Titus 2:5, 8).[56] We can therefore conclude that Jesus and Paul modeled and taught that Christians are to engage with the people of the world, and to do it through the cultural norms of that society, with the exception being when those ways are in contradiction to the ways of God.[57] And the primary reason for this is because it is the best method for effectively fulfilling the Great Commission. Christians Are To Engage with the World Through Culture All Christians are Cross Cultural Missionaries As a church we support many missionaries domestically and abroad. Many of them are cross-cultural missionaries. And decades of missionary work have shown that the most effective manner of evangelism is for the missionaries to insert themselves into the local culture so that they can learn how to share the gospel in the manner that will have the most resonance to that specific people.[58] They learn the language, they learn the customs, they learn their songs, their food, their stories, their myths, and they internalize this cultural knowledge to show that they care about the people they are engaging with, and then they introduce the gospel. It’s the longstanding evangelist’s adage: “People don’t care what you know, until they know that you care.” Even if one takes the view that cultural participation should be minimal and only focused on evangelism, this is self-defeating because the evangelist is still dependent on living in and engaging with culture because that is where the people are. Just as with Jesus and Paul, our common touchpoints in culture are what give us an audience with non-believers. We can’t live away from culture on a mountain-top where we focus on our personal holiness, and then come down and expect to have a hearing from people that we have nothing in common with. I submit that the Sermon on the Mount calls us all to be cross-cultural missionaries, in our neighborhoods and with the people living in the houses right next door to us. We are to understand our neighbors, and then engage with them according to the new kingdom ethics of the Sermon, which are by their nature counter-cultural, so that our neighbors will see our good works, which will reveal the Father to them. Relational Evangelism It’s necessary for us to know what is happening politically, with entertainment, with sports teams, with the arts. It enables us to connect with those we are trying to reach with the gospel.[59] Common cultural activities—hunting, arts and crafts, the latest ideas on how to raise children, going to museums, mountain biking, TV shows— are the best way to establish meaningful relationships with non-believers, and relational evangelism is the primary and best way in which evangelism takes place. For example, even as we (perhaps) agree with a neighbor about the evils of allowing minors to undergo transgender surgeries without parental knowledge, and we rail against those who enable this, we can also include that we are praying for these children and their parents and are supporting organizations that are reaching out to the children to get them the kind of help they may need. Yes, we can be working politically, but by remembering that at their root these are spiritual battles and not just political battles, we are showing our neighbor that we care about the people and not just the issue. We don’t want to win an argument; we want people to be set free and to know Jesus. This will distinguish Christians from other political groups, and this too will get the attention of our neighbor when they hear us being opposed to evil, but also caring for the individual that is being destroyed by the evil and the lies. This is a message they will not always hear from the world. This is being salt and light. If we engage in all of our cultural activities in a uniquely Christian manner, i.e., by adhering to the Sermon on the Mount, we are demonstrating that the gospel isn’t something that is just taught in children’s Sunday School. The way in which we engage in these shared activities demonstrate that the gospel applies to all areas of life, perhaps in ways that a non-believer would never have considered. Full Cultural Disengagement Isn’t Possible Additionally, it is not feasible to entirely disengage from the culture or the world. This is because Christians are dependent on culture, and because we are a part of any culture we reside within. The Christians that lived within the Roman Empire during the first three centuries of the Church’s existence, lived and fashioned a form of Christianity that was bound by the culture within which they lived. But they also influenced it because by the time of Constantine, even though they had no standing in that culture and no ability to change the laws or the cultural practices, by living out their faith according to the Sermon on the Mount, they completely changed the Roman Empire.[60] The nineteenth century author Leo Tolstoy attempted to completely withdraw from the world, and even came to have this worldview named after him—The Tolstoyan Movement. But even he couldn’t live up to his noble but ultimately unobtainable ideals, because we are all dependent and interwoven with the culture around us. He withdrew to such a point that he no longer provided for his wife and family, and he died a broken man, with a family that hated him.[61] How we conduct ourselves at work, or if we start a new business, if we vote, if we hold fund raisers, or work at a community pregnancy center, if we volunteer at Sharlot Hall or the Grand Canyon, if we write a community newsletter, if we coach a little-league team or we create art, or write books—not to mention everything we do at church—we are engaging with the world and the culture around us, and we are shaping it and being shaped by it.[62] Conclusion Following the model and teachings of Jesus and Paul, we are called to cross-culturally engage with the people in the world, while shunning the ways of the world, by following the ethics of the Sermon on the Mount, and by connecting with our neighbors through all available common cultural touchpoints. This will make us effective ambassadors for Christ and continue his mission to save the world.Download this articleGo to part 5 Footnotes 34 Matt. 24:35; 1 Cor. 7:31; 2 Tim. 2:4; 1 Peter 1:2; 2 Peter 3:10; Rev. 21:1-4. 35 Dutch theologian and statesman Abraham Kuyper, who devoted his life to societal and cultural reforms in the Netherlands, and particularly during his time as Prime Minister from 1901 – 1905. 36 Densmore, James. “Biblical Foundations - The Church and the Government.” Keeping in Touch, 1 July 2024. Please contact the church office for a copy. 37 Phil. 2:1-10 38 Strong’s Greek: 2889. κόσμος (kosmos) -- order, the world. (n.d.). https://biblehub.com/greek/2889.htm 39 Dictionary.com | Meanings & Definitions of English Words. (2020a). In Dictionary.com. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/culture 40 The Greek word translated “carpenter” can also apply to a mason, smith or an artisan in general. Strong’s Greek: 5045. τέκτων (tektón) -- a craftsman, spec. a carpenter. (n.d.). https://biblehub.com/greek/5045.htm 41 Mark 6:1-6 42 Matt. 17:24-27; Luke 19:20-26 43 Staff, B. a. S. (2019b, April 22). Sepphoris Inscriptions Reference Rabbis - Biblical Archaeology Society. Biblical Archaeology Society. https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/news/sepphoris-inscriptions-reference-rabbis/ 44 Mark 2:15; Matt. 9:10; Matt. 11:18-19; Luke 7:36-50, 15:1-2 45 John 2:1-11 46 Matt. 8:5-13 47 See also Acts 10 where God commanded and then persuaded Peter to not separate himself from “the world”, i.e., the unclean Gentiles. 48 At that time, neither Jews nor Christians would have had any say in the form of government or the content of laws or any significant portions of Jewish or Roman culture. So, this would not have been in the thinking of Jesus or his hearers. 49 Acts 18:1-3 50 Phil. 3:1-14 51 Acts 17:16-34 52 Acts 22:22-29, 25:1-12 53 Acts 14:1, 17:1-2, 19:8, 22:1 54 See 1 Cor. 9:19-23 for the full context 55 Eph. 4:18; 1 Thess. 4:11-12, respectively. 56 Christ and Culture in the NT – Ch. 9 57 Even those differences can be powerful avenues for evangelism, when done without judging our neighbor. You can explain why you won’t see a particular movie or Netflix show, or why you avoid social drinking, etc. 58 Whiteman, D. L. (2024). Crossing Cultures with the Gospel: Anthropological Wisdom for Effective Christian Witness. Baker Books. 59 Of course, as stated at the beginning of this article, this doesn’t mean that we engage in practices that are contrary to God’s commands. 60 Schnelle, U. (2020). The First One Hundred Years of Christianity: An Introduction to Its History, Literature, and Development. Baker Academic. 61 Wikipedia contributors. (2024, March 21). Tolstoyan movement. Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tolstoyan_movement 62 Of course, the influences Christians have on their surrounding culture and vice-versa can result in both good and bad results.
June 9, 2024 • 16 Minute Read
To What End - Part 3
Introduction In my previous article, I reviewed and critiqued Eric Metaxas’s book, Letter to the American Church, because it called on the “American” Church to engage with the world, but it did so without providing a foundation for the nature, mission, and work of the Church, nor for the nature, mission, and work of government.[14] This article will endeavor to provide those biblical foundations. Properly so, there are many hundreds of books on this vast and complex subject. This article reflects what I have found to be a solid, biblically based approach, but it is by no means the only approach, and space limitations will restrict this article to being a high-level overview of this topic, but hopefully with enough detail to still be helpful for our church family. Why This Matters Knowing God’s intended purposes for the Church and the government, and how they are intended to interact with each other, is crucial. If we don’t have this foundation, then our efforts at best will be misguided and wasteful, and at worst, damaging to the cause of Christ. But if we have our foundation correct, then we can know we are living according to God’s revealed intentions, and we will be effective ambassadors for Christ. An additional benefit is that we will be equipped with a biblical framework from which we can evaluate political candidates and issues. We can ask and answer questions such as: Which candidate or ballot measure will most effectively ensure that the government is passing laws and exercising its powers and authority —“the sword”—according to God’s design? Which candidate or ballot measure will most effectively guard the “straight-line” issues of biblical morality?[15] Which candidate or ballot measure will ensure that God’s intended purposes for the Church are being protected? We will now examine the institution of the Church and the government from a biblical perspective. The Nature, Mission, and Work of the Church The Nature of the Church This is a concise but comprehensive description of the nature of the Church. The church has its roots in the promises made to God’s people in the Old Testament, particularly that God would bless the world through Abraham’s offspring. While there is continuity between the Old Testament people of God and the church, the church is the community of Jesus, new at Pentecost. As such, the church is the fulfillment of God’s promise to the prophets that he would make a new and better covenant with his people and write his law on their hearts.[16] When Jesus preaches the Sermon on the Mount to his disciples and the crowds, he is explaining what life is to look like in this new community that he’s come to create. It is distinctly different from the Jewish culture of the time, and definitely different from the world. These are some (but not all) of the new ethics that are to distinguish the lives of the members of this new community. The poor, those who mourn, who are humble, who hunger and thirst for justice, who are merciful, whose hearts are pure, who work for peace and who are persecuted for doing right are blessed and the Kingdom of Heaven is theirs. (Matt. 5:3-10) Reconciliation and mercy over justice (Matt. 5:21-26, 38-42) Sexual purity over lust, and marriage fidelity over convenience (Matt. 5:27-32) Love of enemies over hate (Matt. 5:43-48,7:12) Spiritual authenticity over hypocrisy (Matt. 6:1-18, 7:1-6) Trust in God over your own capabilities (Matt. 6:19-34)[17] When this community assembles locally it is called the church and it is where divine spiritual activities will occur, because Jesus is present. This is unique to the church. Exercising the keys of the kingdom (Matt. 16:18–19) Conducting discipline according to the Sermon on the Mount (Matt. 18:15–17) Preaching the gospel (2 Tim. 4:1–5) Baptizing and making disciples of Christ (Matt. 28:19–20) Worshiping corporately in song (Eph. 5:19; Col. 3:16) Celebrating the Lord’s Supper (1 Cor. 11:17–34) Ordaining ministers (1 Tim. 4:14; Titus 1:5–9)[18] Notice the special nature of the ethics and the activities of this community, and how contrary they are to those in the world at large, or even the Jewish culture of Jesus’s time. The Mission of the Church To understand the mission for the Church we have to first understand the mission of Jesus, the Church’s Head.[19] For the Son of Man came to seek and to save the lost. (Luke 19:10)[20] The true light, which gives light to everyone, was coming into the world. He was in the world, and the world was made through him, yet the world did not know him. He came to his own, and his own people did not receive him. But to all who did receive him, who believed in his name, he gave the right to become children of God, who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man, but of God. (John 1:9-13)[21] Jesus was sent by his Father to save the world, by making his Father known to the world, through trusting in the person and work of Jesus. To be sure, there are significant additional facets to Jesus’ mission, but at the risk of minimizing this point, his work to save a lost and rebellious people and bring them into an eternal relationship with the Triune God is predominant. The mission of the church is to continue Jesus’s mission.[22] Now the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to the mountain to which Jesus had directed them. And when they saw him they worshiped him, but some doubted. And Jesus came and said to them, ‘All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you. And behold, I am with you always, to the end of the age.’ (Matt. 28:16-20) God, in his unfathomable providence, has commanded, entrusted, and equipped his followers with the marvelous privilege of being instrumental in the work of growing God’s family, by going into all of the nations and making disciples. God sent Jesus and now Jesus sends us. And this is further revealed and confirmed as the mission of the church throughout the book of Acts, as the disciples obeyed Jesus’s Great Commission and made disciples of the world.[23] The Church’s mission is to be evangelists and to make disciples. The Work of the Church The works of the Church are numerous, and as we have learned through Pastor’s Matt’s excellent teachings on the book of Ephesians, chapter 4:11-16 arguably provides the most best description of the work that the local church is called to do for its members, in the service of Christ.[24] And he (Jesus) gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, so that we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes. Rather, speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ, from whom the whole body, joined and held together by every joint with which it is equipped, when each part is working properly, makes the body grow so that it builds itself up in love. (Eph. 4:11-16) Jesus has gifted the church with the ministers necessary to disciple and build the people of God’s family into Christlikeness and into a body unified by love. This is the primary work of the local church. And the New Testament Epistles written to the churches are principally about encouraging, correcting, teaching, instructing and training the members of churches to this end, for the glory of Christ. In summary, the church is God’s ongoing fulfillment of his promise to create a people for himself, where the gospel is proclaimed and experienced through divine spiritual happenings, and where God’s gifted leaders equip and grow his church into a spiritually mature community that is being discipled and is making disciples, while loving one another. The Nature, “Mission”, and Work of Government[25] The Nature of Government As American Citizens, we are very familiar (hopefully!) with these revolutionary words: We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. —That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,[26] As Americans, our founding Fathers and founding documents declare that the unalienable rights men have come from our Creator, and to ensure that these rights are protected, a government has been created by men which derives its powers from the mutual consensus of those people who are forming the government. In other words, the people create a government, and they willingly agree to transfer power to this government, and to then obey this government’s appropriate exercise of that delegated power over their lives. But the Scriptures teach that government is an institution created by God not by men, and the power that it has comes from God. This appointment can be seen in Genesis 9, after Noah and his family emerged from the ark after the destruction of the flood. And for your lifeblood I will require a reckoning: from every beast I will require it and from man. From his fellow man I will require a reckoning for the life of man. ‘Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed, for God made man in his own image.’ And you, be fruitful and multiply, increase greatly on the earth and multiply in it.[27] Note that God uses the phrase “I will require” three times. God is the authority behind the delegated authority he gives to worldly government and to whom governments ultimately answer. But it will be the government that will be the one exercising this reckoning, on God’s behalf. This is God’s decree for the creation of government and for government to have the right to use force against its citizens, but only in a proportional manner.[28] The Mission of Government From Genesis 9, we can then deduce three God ordained primary purposes for government—its mission. First, to render judgment for the sake of justice. Justice executed is to be proportional to the crime. “A life for a life.” This authorizes tremendous power to government—the ability to take a life—but it also limits government so that it doesn’t overstep its authority. Implicit in this command is that governments should protect the lives of its citizens. The life of a citizen is so valuable that if someone takes a life, their life is forfeited. Therefore, those lives must also be protected from harm, whether from other citizens or invaders. Second, to build platforms of peace, order, and flourishing. The provisions for the government to provide justice and safety in vv. 5-6 are the necessary prerequisites for being able to fulfill the command to (re)populate the earth in v. 7. “By justice a king builds up the land.” (Pro. 29:4; also, 16:12, 15). In other words, governments exist to build a platform on which human beings can pursue God’s dominion mandate.29 And we see this same principle taught by Paul to Timothy: First of all, then, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people, for kings and all who are in high positions, that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way. (1 Tim. 2:1-2) Third, to set the stage for redemption. Paul first says we are to pray for our leaders so that we may lead a peaceful and quiet and godly life. Here is the rest of Paul’s teaching: This is good, and it is pleasing in the sight of God our Savior, who desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth. (1 Tim. 2:3-4) When we follow vv. 1-2, vv. 3-4 we then enable “people to be saved and come to the knowledge of the truth”, and this happens primarily through the exemplary lives of Christians, who are free to live and worship as Christians and evangelize their neighbors, who are also free to then live out their Christian lives.[30] People must learn to read before they can read the Bible. People must eat healthy food and breathe nontoxic air so that they can live, “that they may know God, and worship him. Children benefit by having loving parents so that they can better apprehend the love of God the Father. Do you see? God means for the stuff of ordinary, everyday life to serve the purposes of salvation and eternity.[31] So, the mission for the government, ultimately, is to support the mission of the church. The Work of the Government One of the primary ways in which government fulfills its mission, as described above, is to “wield the sword.” We first saw this in Genesis 9, where God requires a reckoning. And then Paul teaches the same principle. For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval for he is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer. (Rom. 13:3-4) Having the authority to punish and hold people accountable to the law is the instrumentation that the government brandishes “to protect life, enable the cultural mandate, and provide a platform for the work of the church.”[32] And Peter then teaches that we are to submit to this action. Be subject for the Lord's sake to every human institution, whether it be to the emperor as supreme, or to governors as sent by him to punish those who do evil and to praise those who do good. For this is the will of God, that by doing good you should put to silence the ignorance of foolish people. (1 Pet. 2:13-15) Conclusion God has established both institutions—the Church and the government—and granted them authority in two different realms. The church has been given the “keys to the kingdom” and the government has been given the power of “the sword”. Each institution is designed to exercise its authority in its own realm and to not exercise authority in the other. For example, it is not within the purview of the church to punish people outside the church for breaking the law or for theological heresy. And it is not within the purview of the government to establish how people are to worship God or to hold people accountable for their theology. Ultimately, both governments and churches serve God’s purpose of calling all people to worship him, the former indirectly, the latter directly. The government’s work is a prerequisite to the mission of the church and salvation, just as learning to read is a prerequisite to reading the Bible.[33] However, this does not mean that these two institutions are to never associate, in fact, it is inevitable that they will. And now that we have established a biblical basis for the nature, mission, and works of these two complementary organizations (see Fig. 1 following for a helpful chart), in our next series of articles, we will address how they are intended to interact, and how we as Christians, are intended to act in relation to both. Fig. 1. A Comparison of Functions Between the Church and the State from: Button, Stephen.Download this articleGo to part 4 Footnotes [14] Strictly speaking, Metaxas’s book was addressing Christian engagement with the broader subject of “the world”, not only the government. But this article will broach the larger topic of Christian engagement with the world by beginning with the government, which was an emphasis by Metaxas. Additional aspects of “the world” will be covered in subsequent articles. [15] Kottman, Matt. “Politics and the Unity of the Church.” Solid Rock Christian Fellowship: Keeping in Touch Newsletter, June 2024. Contact the church office if you’d like a copy. [16] Morgan, C. (2021, February 10). The origin and nature of the church. The Gospel Coalition. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/essay/origin-nature-church/. The author is summarizing numerous Scriptures, but particularly Jer. 31; Rom. 11:27; Heb. 8:8-12, 10:16-17; by allusion Matt. 26:28; Mark 14:24; John 6:45 [17] David VanDrunnen, Living in God’s Two Kingdoms: A Biblical Vision for Christianity and Culture (Illinois: Crossway Books, 2010), chap. 6, Kindle. [18] VanDrunnen. Ibid. [19] Eph. 5:23; Col. 1:18 [20] All Scripture quoted is ESV. [21] See also John 3:16-17, 17:1-3 [22] DeYoung, K. (2024, March 27). The mission of the church. The Gospel Coalition. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/essay/the-mission-of-the-church/ [23] Ibid. [24] Pastor Matt Kottman. “Church Unity and Maturity.” November 19, 2023. https://vimeo.com/886634696 [25] Jonathan Leeman, How the Nations Rage: Rethinking Faith and Politics in a Divided Age (Tennessee: Nelson Books, 2018), chap. 5, Kindle. I am indebted to Mr. Leeman for providing much of the content for this section. I have relied on it heavily because it is the best treatment on this subject that I have found. [26] Declaration of Independence: a transcription. (2023, October 11). National Archives. https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/declaration-transcript [27] Gen. 9:5-7 [28] See also Rom. 13:1-7; Titus 3:1-2 [29] Leeman. Ibid. [30] Of course, God works through cultures where this isn’t the case, but that is necessitated due to the government’s disobedience to God’s decrees. God’s Providence works in spite of and through the world’s disobedience (and ours). [31] Leeman. Ibid. [32] Ibid.
April 29, 2024 • 14 Minute Read
To What End - Part 1
We live in a time of considerable turmoil, both politically and culturally. The news is replete with headlines that only a handful of years ago would have been unimaginable. And our cultural trajectory appears to be unrelentingly “slouching towards Gomorrah”, as Robert Bork perceptively diagnosed in his well-known 2003 book of the same title.[1] The current state of affairs shocks many of us, and it raises the perennial question of how should the church engage with the culture in which we live? And what does the current state of worldly affairs reveal about the current state of the American Church? Eric Metaxas, a cultural commentator, self-described ecumenical Christian, and eclectic author of over thirty books,[2] provides an answer to this question in his book Letter to the American Church (Salem Books, 2022). His response is based heavily on the research he conducted for his bestselling biography of the WWII era German Lutheran pastor, theologian and anti-Nazi dissident, Dietrich Bonhoeffer.[3] Metaxas exhorts the American Church to learn from Bonhoeffer’s example and see the obvious future societal calamities on the horizon and to speak fearlessly, in faith, to the governing powers and institutions. Metaxas’ additional admonition is to not repeat the mistakes of the German Lutheran Church, which was too closely aligned with the values of the German State, and had become a “Christless Christianity”. The German Church had also ignored Bonhoeffer’s prophetic warnings to push back against the societal evils, which then resulted in calamity for Germany and the rest of the world. Metaxas’ view can be summarized as follows. The American Church should be like Bonhoeffer in criticizing American culture. The American Church should not be like the German Church and ignore Bonhoeffer’s warnings to return to our First Love, and to speak out against the evils in the world. The church should repent from its unjustifiable and mistaken withdrawal from the world, return to our First Love, and speak out forcefully, in faith, demonstrating that we actually believe in God. Pastoral Considerations While this polarizing topic of cultural engagement can be seen from a number of perspectives—political, cultural, historical, eschatological,[4] and even from the perspective of our individual courage, faith, and obedience (or lack thereof)—what is at stake is nothing less than God’s purposes for his church. Within this context, it is the God-ordained role of the elders of a church to evaluate and discern if the counsel of Metaxas’ book is aligned with what God has divinely revealed for his church at the local level. “Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood.” (Acts 20:28) Note that the church is the family that God has “obtained with his own blood.” This is a sobering reminder to those that God has put over his flock of how precious his church is to him, and to the infinite cost that he has expended on purchasing a people for himself.[5] Therefore, one must tread with the utmost humility and care when declaring what God has purposed for his blood-purchased people. Additionally, Metaxas’ rebukes of the American Church can create in his readers (this reviewer included), an emotional and visceral response of outrage to the perceived failures of the American Church. However, Metaxas’ reproaches can and should be first directed at our individual failures to stand up to the culture, because we are a part of the American Church. In an effort to not attend to our personal guilt and disapproval about our lack of faithful and courageous engagement, we can readily transfer our inwardly focused anger outwardly at the Church, and consequently onto our local church leaders. We can be expecting them to do what we should be doing. Our response to this question of the church and culture should begin with what our individual responsibilities are, particularly given that we live in a representative republic where we have the inestimable privilege of having a substantial say in our government and its policies. Only then should we give attention to an institutional response. Jesus’ rhetorical question of “Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye?” is painfully applicable to this situation.[6] Therefore, our (perhaps) justifiably stirred-up anger and emotions and righteous indignation must be tempered with a well-considered and biblical response to the issues facing the church and should not be driven by an emotional or ill-conceived or reckless reaction to the immediacy with which we think we must respond to our cultural situation. We must always keep in mind that it is to Jesus, who is the head of his Church, that we will all give an account. Therefore, we must endeavor to ensure that we are not futilely expending our time and resources on activities that are contrary to God’s desires. The answer to the question of the role of the Church in regard to cultural engagement is not primarily about societal or political consequences, or even the future of the “American Church” or of America, it is of cosmological and infinite importance. Ultimately, it is about God’s declared purpose for his church, and therefore about the role of the leaders that God has put in place to shepherd his church, and about the role of each of us in being obedient to God’s call on our lives. These are the primary considerations with which Metaxas’ book will and must be evaluated. And this is the underlying reason for calling this series “To What End?” All discourses—cultural, apologetic, political, doctrinal, ecclesiological—should be considered through the lens of this question. What are we trying to accomplish with this discourse, and does it align with God’s revealed purposes? An Evaluation of Metaxas’ Answer The Role of the Church The first premise of Metaxas’ answer is based on his understanding of God’s call for the American Church. “We should underscore the idea that the centrality of our nation in the world does not mean that we are intrinsically exceptional, but rather that God has sovereignly chosen us to hold the torch of liberty for all the world, and that the Church is central to our doing this.”[7] Metaxas’ provides a rejoinder to those who would disagree with this statement. “If anyone would feel that believing God has chosen the American Church for such a vital role somehow smacks of an egotistical nationalism, they have already bought into the Marxist and globalist lie that America is nothing special – or is probably a force for evil at this point.”[8] There are two primary problems with these statements.[9] The first problem is that God’s purpose for the American Church and America is simply an assertion for which biblical or other substantiation is not—nor can it be—provided. It presupposes that Metaxas knows with certainty what God is doing with America and the American Church at this specific moment in history. Humility should be our guide when making pronouncements of what God is doing in his creation and should be confined to the unequivocally clear, timeless, and historically orthodox teachings of Scripture. We must take great care to not equate America and the Church too closely.[10] The second problem is that the validity of this claim must be evaluated by starting with a biblical definition for the role and purpose of the Church. Even though Metaxas properly raises this question in Chapter One, “What is the Church?”, he doesn’t answer with a Scriptural definition of the church. The best answer this reviewer can ascertain is that the church is truly the church when it is faithfully speaking out against the world. But this doesn’t address who and what the church is, but states what the church does. A correct understanding of the first element (what the church is) is essential to getting the second element correct (what the church then does as a result of what it is).[11] Because this fundamental premise that God has “sovereignly chosen” America/the American Church for the specific purpose of confronting culture is simply asserted and not substantiated, the resulting prescribed actions may be faulty and should be given very careful consideration.[12] History as Harbinger The warnings from the WWII era have validity for us today. We have much to learn from the courageous life and message of Bonhoeffer, who fearlessly spoke out at great risk to his life, and we can learn from the intransigence of the German Church which ignored Bonhoeffer’s warnings about the degradation of its obedience to Christ. The German Church had adopted, implicitly and explicitly—or was silent—regarding the abominable beliefs of the Nazi regime. We see something similar happening today in portions of the American Church as it adopts the world’s value on issues of humanity and sexuality, through militant feminism, LGBTQ issues, transgenderism, and even abortion. The abandonment of Christ is the underlying issue that led to the silence of the German Church in the face of the evils of the Nazi state, as both Bonhoeffer and Metaxas correctly point out. The call to the Church—then and now—to return to Christ is appropriate and essential. But this is where Metaxas’ prescription falls short, lacks specificity, and is misguided. His exhortations for the church to rebuke the world’s values are timelessly relevant to the institutional church and should be heeded, but his remedy is to urge the church to not keep focusing on “Bible studies and sermons”, on “business as usual”, and to not “hide behind the idol of evangelism.” This counsel is misguided. It’s not the activities that should be shunned, it’s the content of these activities that needs to be revivified. The American Church today (and the German Church of old) are adopting the views of the world because of what is being taught in our Bible studies and sermons, and because of a feckless and “easy believism” evangelistic message. In short, the fullness of the gospel is being neutered and made subservient to the world’s ideals. These disciplines need to be fully saturated with the gospel and it needs to be preached and taught and modeled by the churches and their leadership that the gospel is for every aspect of life. If this is the emphasis, then the church would not adopt the mores of the world. If those in leadership (and those sitting in the seats) adhered to the admonitions of the Psalmist when it comes to listening to the world or to the Word, these issues plaguing the church would fade into irrelevance. "May your unfailing love come to me, Lord, your salvation, according to your promise; then I can answer anyone who taunts me, for I trust in your word. Never take your word of truth from my mouth, for I have put my hope in your laws. I will always obey your law, for ever and ever. I will walk about in freedom, for I have sought out your precepts. I will speak of your statutes before kings and will not be put to shame, for I delight in your commands because I love them. I reach out for your commands, which I love, that I may meditate on your decrees.” (Psalm 119:41-48) This is the antidote to the issues Metaxas raises. A church focused on Christ will not adopt nor acquiesce to the values or demands of the culture. A church focused on Christ will not align with the state. A church focused on Christ will make disciples that are focused on Christ, and those disciples will transform the world around them, one person at a time, when they are obediently loving God and loving their neighbor as themselves. Additionally, Metaxas’ call for the church to “return to Christ” seems to be a means to an end. Granted, it is for the eminently noble end of staving off WWII type material atrocities in our time, but this should be considered a result of the church’s adherence to the gospel, not the purpose of the church’s adherence to the gospel, which is to be focused on addressing the underlying cause of the world’s suffering—it’s spiritual suffering. We have to remember that we don’t fight as the world fights, and therefore, the church’s response to the world must be distinctly Christian in nature, otherwise, the church only becomes another political party fighting for dominance in the public arena of ideas.13 The “American Church” Metaxas does not define who and what constitutes the “American Church”. It is a sweeping indictment that is leveled without specificity. If Metaxas’ concern is about the churches that have abandoned the gospel, which is clearly the case for some denominations, he should call out those denominations and enumerate the charges against them. The churches that are leaving those denominations, in some cases after hundreds of years, are suffering the consequences that come from their decision to divide. This distress consists of the internal anguish within their congregations caused by the separation and the knowledge that the onlooking world will use this very public disunity to further damage the cause of Christ. On the other hand, taking a principled stand on these issues—to the point of painful and public separation—is speaking truth to the world by demonstrating that these issues are so important, they are worth the cost of disunity. These churches are exhibiting exactly the kind of gospel-centered fearlessness that Metaxas is accusing them of not possessing and would very likely take exception with Metaxas’ criticism. Conclusion This book was challenging to review. It is a case where the individual criticisms pointed at the Church have some validity and caused this reviewer to frequently say “Amen”, but when considered as a cohesive argument, they don’t lead to the prescribed remedies, which unfortunately lean toward being reactionary, not well substantiated, and emotional. While granting that Metaxas’ book is intended to be a polemic against the current state of the Church, the lack of specifics on how the Church is to execute his instructions is also detrimental to his charge, and if he is incorrect in his prescriptions, could lead the Church away from God’s intended purposes. The Church should be more courageous, it should focus on Christ, it should not become complacent, it should not adopt the world’s values, and yes, it should be an institution that provides relief to the world’s suffering. But how this is accomplished is just as important as what it is trying to accomplish. And this is what will be discussed in more depth in the next series of articles.Download this articleGo to part 2 Footnotes [1] Bork, Robert. Slouching Towards Gomorrah. (Harper-Collins. 2010). [2] Eric Metaxas. (2024, April 11). Home - Eric Metaxas. Eric Metaxas -. https://ericmetaxas.com/ [3] Metaxas, E. (2010). Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy: a Righteous Gentile vs. the Third Reich. (Thomas Nelson. 2011). [4] Eschatological – the theological doctrine of last things [5] 1 Corinthians 6:20; 7:23 [6] Matthew 7:1-5 [7] Metaxas, Eric. “Introduction.” Letter to the American Church, Kindle Edition, Salem Books, 2022, p. 8. [8] Ibid, p. 10. [9] Ascribing this primary purpose to the church is an anemic ecclesiology (the doctrine of the nature and structure of the church). To be fair, this book is not a treatise on the church, but Metaxas does not include or acknowledge any other purposes for the church. Additionally, the charge that those who disagree with his stated purpose for the church are agreeing with an evil ideology, shuts down conflicting opinions and discussion. [10] Schreiner, P. (2023, April 26). The good, the bad, and the ugly of Christian nationalism. The Gospel Coalition. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/good-bad-ugly-christian-nationalism/ [11] A biblically rooted understanding of the role and purpose of the church will be covered in subsequent articles. [12] However, this doesn’t mean that there are no valid reasons or methods for the church to engage the culture. A positive case for the role and manner in which the church engages culture will be addressed in subsequent articles. [13] 1 Corinthians 1:20-31; 2 Corinthians 10:1-6; Perhaps Colossians 2 (the context is not political, but the principle is the same – don’t submit to the rules of the world).