Free Yet Transforming

Matt Kottman • Lead Pastor/Elder
August 18, 2025

37 Minute Read

1. Introduction

In the ongoing struggle to faithfully articulate the heart of the Christian gospel, evangelical churches today face recurring challenges from theological systems that risk distorting the message of salvation by grace through faith. One significant movement in this arena is “Free Grace Theology” (FGT),[1] which, in its quest to protect the doctrine of sola fide ("faith alone"), has redefined saving faith as a mere act of intellectual assent, separated from repentance, obedience, and transformation. While FGT affirms that salvation is exclusively the gift of God, received through faith apart from any works, it interprets biblical faith in such a narrow manner that it routinely severs justification from sanctification, and assurance from perseverance in the Christian life.

This paper seeks to offer a comprehensive historical, biblical, and pastoral critique of FGT. With a spirit of charitable concern, and a commitment to the clarity and fullness of the gospel, the following analysis argues that the witness of Scripture and the testimony of historic Christianity both affirm that authentic faith in Christ is inseparably linked to repentance, transformation, and obedience—in other words, that while faith alone justifies, justifying faith is never alone. This paper will examine FGT in terms of its definition, development, theological claims, exegetical arguments, and practical consequences, seeking to uphold the historic Protestant and biblical account of salvation which, far from undermining grace, vindicates it by showing that grace not only pardons but also transforms.

As this paper will argue, FGT is a departure from an orthodox view of salvation, however this does not mean that those who hold this view, and are repenting of sin and hoping in Christ are not saved. There are many faithful Christians who hold this view and we should treat them as brothers and sisters in Christ. However, this in no way validates FGT. It does however call us to engage and discuss these issues with Christian charity. For if you have all knowledge and all faith but have not love, you are nothing (1 Cor 13:2).

2. Historical Context

2.1. The Development of Lordship Salvation

The Lordship Salvation movement emphasizes that saving faith in Christ is never abstract or merely intellectual but involves submission to Christ as Lord resulting in repentance from sin. Though the term “Lordship Salvation” gained widespread attention in the 1980s, the concept itself is deeply rooted in historic theology.

Even in the earliest centuries of the church, leaders connected faith and repentance inseparably. Clement of Rome (c. 35 – c. 99 AD) wrote:

Let us attend to what is good, pleasing, and acceptable in the sight of Him who formed us. Let us look steadfastly to the blood of Christ, and see how precious that blood is to God which, having been shed for our salvation, has set the grace of repentance before the whole world… from generation to generation, the Lord has granted a place of repentance to all such as would be converted unto Him.[2]

Ignatius of Antioch (c. 35 – c. 108 AD) called believers to repent and turn to a true faith in Christ’s passion, implying that without repentance, faith is not genuine.[3] Justin Martyr (c. 100 – c. 165 AD) stated, “Those who are found not living as he taught should know that they are not really Christians, even if his teachings are on their lips, for he said that not those who merely profess but those who also do the works will be saved.”[4] Tertullian (c. 155 – c. 240 AD) likewise saw repentance as integral to forgiveness, “we confess our sins to the Lord… of confession repentance is born; by repentance God is appeased.”[5] Gregory the Great (c. 540-604 AD) wrote, “For whosoever mourns past transgressions, yet forsakes them not ... subjects himself to the penalty of more grievous sin They cleanse themselves in vain by their weeping, if they wickedly defile themselves in their living.”[6]

The Reformers consistently taught that genuine faith produces repentance and obedience as evidence of salvation. Martin Luther’s comments in his Galatians commentary yield insight. Galatians 5:6 reads,

“For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision counts for anything, but only faith working through love.” Luther points out that a true faith is a working faith. He wrote, “[H]e that will be a true Christian, must be a true believer. Now he believeth not truly, if works and charity [love] follow not faith….”[7]

Similarly, confessional documents such as the Westminster Confession of Faith affirm that faith always involves a turning from sin:

“Faith, thus receiving and resting on Christ and His righteousness, is the alone instrument of justification: yet it is not alone in the person justified, but is ever accompanied with all other saving graces, and is never without hope, love, and repentance.”[8]

The London Baptist Confession of 1689 states, “These good works, done in obedience to God’s commandments, are the fruit and evidence of a true and living faith.”[9]

Even the Arminian founder of the Methodist Church, John Wesley said, “We are justified without the works of the law, as any previous condition of justification; but they are an immediate fruit of that faith whereby we are justified. So that if good works do not follow our faith, even all inward and outward holiness, it is plain our faith is nothing worth; we are yet in our sins.”[10]

Billy Graham put it this way, “Only as we bow in contrition, confession, and repentance at the foot of the Cross, can we find forgiveness.”[11]

Historically, this understanding formed the consensus of orthodox Christianity: true faith is inseparable from repentance which results in life transformation.

2.2. The Emergence of Free Grace Theology

FGT, by contrast, is a late twentieth-century development. The Grace Evangelical Society (GES), founded in 1986 by Robert Wilkin, and prominent figures such as Zane Hodges, sought to counter what they perceived as a legalistic distortion in Lordship Salvation.[12] Hodges and his colleagues argued that the gospel guarantees eternal life to anyone who believes, regardless of repentance, discipleship, or obedience. Key works like The Gospel Under Siege (1981) and Absolutely Free! (1989) explicitly articulate this position.

FGT is therefore reactive in nature: it was formulated as a response to the Lordship Salvation emphasis popularized by John MacArthur’s The Gospel According to Jesus (1988) and other evangelical leaders who stressed the inseparability of faith and obedience.[13] FGT claims its view shows the “freeness of grace,” but it redefines that freeness in a way that deviates from historic orthodoxy, reducing it to intellectual assent, by removing repentance from it. The name “Free Grace Theology” is a name that its proponents came up with for themselves. One should not read the phrase free grace in the title and assume that other understandings of salvation are importing a merited grace idea. Free grace is what they see themselves as defending, however this paper will make clear that FGT fails to live up to its namesake.

2.3. Distinguishing FGT from Historic Orthodoxy

It is important to recognize that FGT does not reject the freeness of God’s grace; rather, it reinterprets grace. Historic Christian theology affirms that salvation is a free gift of God, not merited by works (Eph. 2:8–9).[14] Yet, that grace is never inactive. Genuine grace inevitably produces repentance, good works, and obedience to God’s commands. The novelty of FGT lies not in its affirmation of free grace but in its separation of grace from repentance and the ongoing transformation of the believer’s life—a separation unsupported by Scripture and historic confessions.

3. Biblical Evidence for the Inseparability of Faith and Repentance

3.1. The Gospel Call Mark 1:15

“and saying, ‘The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel.’” (Mark 1:15)

Jesus inaugurated his public ministry with a concise yet profound proclamation, “The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel” (Mark 1:15).[15]

This verse immediately links repentance with faith as the response to the gospel. The command to “repent and believe” is not sequential in a purely chronological sense but relational and conceptual: true belief necessarily entails turning from sin and turning toward God. Jesus’ use of both terms together indicates that faith cannot exist in isolation; it is a holistic orientation of the heart and life toward God.

The Greek word metanoia means to “feel remorse, repent, be converted.”[16] It is a reorientation of life. When combined with faith, it emphasizes that genuine trust in God produces an active rejection of sin and a life turned toward obedience. In other words, repentance is not an optional add-on to faith; it is an intrinsic aspect of faith in Christ.

3.2. Apostolic Teaching

3.2.1. Acts 14:15

“Men, why are you doing these things? We also are men, of like nature with you, and we bring you good news, that you should turn from these vain things to a living God, who made the heaven and the earth and the sea and all that is in them.” (Acts 14:15)

In Lystra, Paul declares the gospel as a call to turn “from these vain things” to “a living God.” While the word “repentance” is not explicitly used, the concept is embedded in the language of turning. Here repentance is a transfer of trust—from dead idols to the living Creator. This illustrates why repentance and faith are inseparable: to repent is to redirect trust from one object to another. In biblical terms, repentance is faith forsaking one object and embracing another.

3.2.2. Acts 20:21

“testifying both to Jews and to Greeks of repentance toward God and of faith in our Lord Jesus Christ.” (Acts 20:21)

The Apostle Paul summarizes his evangelistic mission as “…testifying both to Jews and Greeks of repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ” (Acts 20:21)

Paul explicitly pairs repentance with faith, framing them as complementary responses to the gospel. The Greek construction of this phrase demonstrates that repentance is directed toward God and faith is directed toward Christ. This dual focus indicates the holistic nature of conversion: one turns from sin to God while simultaneously trusting in Christ for salvation.

This pairing is elsewhere in the New Testament, particularly in the preaching of Peter (Acts 2:38) and John the Baptist (Matt 3:2), consistently presenting repentance and faith as inseparable dimensions of a biblical response to God’s call.

3.2.3. Acts 26:20

“but declared first to those in Damascus, then in Jerusalem and throughout all the region of Judea, and also to the Gentiles, that they should repent and turn to God, performing deeds in keeping with their repentance.” (Acts 26:20)

As the gospel call was given both to Jews and Gentiles, everyone is called to repent and turn to God. To turn away from one thing is to turn to another. The act of repentance is also the act of turning to God. Both of these can be encapsulated in the concept of genuine faith. The text does not communicate repentance and turning to God as two separate and distinct things. This is clear in how the verse ends by reemphasizing genuine repentance. He is not speaking about repentance then turning to God as a separate concept, then returning again to repentance. There is more continuity in the argument than that. He is speaking of one thing which is a turning from sin which is (in the same act) a turning to God. One cannot turn to God if he is not simultaneously turning from sin.

3.3. Faith Manifested in Works

3.3.1. Matthew 7:17-20

“So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit. A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit. Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. Thus you will recognize them by their fruits.” (Matt 7:17-20)

Jesus is speaking about false prophets in this passage, but he speaks about a general reality. We produce what we are. If a person has faith in Christ, meaning the Spirit of God dwells in him and he is a new creation, having a new heart (Rom 8:9; 2 Cor 5:17; Ezek 36:26), then he will bear fruit that is consistent with this new nature. Therefore, according to Jesus, it is not unreasonable to look at a person’s fruit/works for insight into whether that person is a genuine Christian.

Some arguing against this would suggest that this expects perfect obedience. But the Scriptures are clear that we stumble in many ways (Jas 3:2). Our whole lives are lives of repentance and sanctification.

3.3.2. James 2:14–26

James 2:14–26 famously addresses the relationship between faith and works, “So also faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead” (Jas 2:17).

James does not deny justification by faith; rather, he emphasizes that true faith inevitably produces good works (life change). Saving faith is never inactive—it manifests itself in obedience, love, and action. The rhetorical argument of James, “Was not Abraham our father justified by works when he offered his son Isaac?” (2:21), illustrates that faith and obedience are intimately linked. Abraham’s willingness to act was the evidence of his saving faith.

3.4. Grace Is not in Vain: 1 Corinthians 15:9–10

“For I am the least of the apostles, unworthy to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the church of God. But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace toward me was not in vain. On the contrary, I worked harder than any of them, though it was not I, but the grace of God that is with me.” (1 Cor 15:9–10)

After defining the gospel and affirming its supremacy to the Corinthians (1 Cor 15:1–8), Paul turns to his own experience as living proof of its power. Once a persecutor of the church, he confesses, “his grace toward me was not in vain.” (1 Cor 15:10).

If God’s grace had left Paul unchanged, it would have been empty and ineffective. Instead, that grace transformed him and energized his labor. In other words, saving grace is never without effect—it always produces change.

3.5. A Grace that Works: Ephesians 2:8–10

“For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast. For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them.” (Eph 2:8–10)

The Apostle Paul leaves no doubt that salvation is by grace. Yet Ephesians 2:8–10 gives the full picture. We are not saved by works, but by grace through a faith that works. We are not saved by works but for works. The conjunction “for” in verse 10 grounds the statement of verses 8–9: works do not save, rather that salvation itself creates us anew resulting in good works. Works are not the cause of salvation but its inevitable result. The same grace that saves also works within us to produce what pleases God.

3.6. Professing and Believing Are not the Same Thing

3.6.1. Titus 1:16

“They profess to know God, but they deny him by their works. They are detestable, disobedient, unfit for any good work.” (Tit 1:16)

Titus is being warned that a profession of faith is only as good as the works that prove that profession. The belief that a person can be in Christ, professing to know God, but not having repented of his sins is categorically denied by the Apostle Paul. A true faith gives evidence of its existence.

3.6.2. James 2:19-20

“You believe that God is one; you do well. Even the demons believe—and shudder! Do you want to be shown, you foolish person, that faith apart from works is useless?” (Jas 2:19–20)

Believing can have more than one meaning. A belief that merely acknowledges the truth of something is no different than the type of belief that demons have, and even the demons shudder! That is to say, they tremble before God. The point James is making in this text is that this kind of faith is of no value. Genuine faith brings with it evidence of that faith. He is not saying that we are saved by works, rather that works are the necessary result of faith. A true faith is a repenting faith.

3.7. Assurance Through Obedience

3.7.1. 1 John 2:3–6

“And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments. Whoever says “I know him” but does not keep his commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in him, but whoever keeps his word, in him truly the love of God is perfected. By this we may know that we are in him: whoever says he abides in him ought to walk in the same way in which he walked.” (1 Jn 2:3–6)

The Apostle John reinforces the connection between faith and life transformation, “And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments. Whoever says “I know him” but does not keep his commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in him,” (1 John 2:3–4).

John’s epistle underscores that genuine knowledge of God—saving faith—produces obedience. Faith is not merely an intellectual claim; it is relational and transformative.[17] The moral and spiritual fruit of obedience functions as both evidence and assurance of salvation. Those who claim belief without obedience may lack true faith, a concern that FGT underemphasizes by separating belief from life change.

3.7.2. Romans 1:16–17; 16:25–27

“For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith for faith, as it is written, “The righteous shall live by faith.” (Rom 1:16–17)

“Now to him who is able to strengthen you according to my gospel and the preaching of Jesus Christ, according to the revelation of the mystery that was kept secret for long ages but has now been disclosed and through the prophetic writings has been made known to all nations, according to the command of the eternal God, to bring about the obedience of faith— to the only wise God be glory forevermore through Jesus Christ! Amen.” (Rom 16:25–27)

The Apostle opens Romans with a declaration of the gospel’s surprising power: it is “the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes” (Rom 1:16). He immediately adds that “the righteousness of God is revealed from faith for faith, as it is written, ‘The righteous shall live by faith’” (Rom 1:17).[18] From the outset, Paul emphasizes that salvation is entirely by faith—faith that both saves and sustains the believer’s life. This, he says, is the gospel.

When Paul closes the letter, he frames the gospel he has proclaimed from start to finish as producing “the obedience of faith” (Rom 16:25–26). Faith in the gospel inevitably issues in obedience. Where there is no obedience, there is no assurance that saving faith is present. Salvation is by grace through faith, but that faith is living—it produces repentance and grows a life of obedience.

3.8. Recap

Across both the Gospels and the Epistles, the biblical witness consistently affirms:

1. Faith and repentance are inseparable — Conversion is one unified act of turning from sin to God and trusting in Christ.

2. The gospel call is holistic — The apostles consistently proclaim repentance toward God and faith in Christ as one response.

3. Saving grace always transforms — The grace that saves also re-creates, energizes, and produces a new life.

4. Works flow from salvation — Good works are the inevitable result of genuine faith, never its cause.

5. Empty profession is exposed — Claims to know God without accompanying change are rejected as false.

6. Obedience gives assurance — A life marked by “the obedience of faith” confirms that grace has been truly received.

These passages collectively demonstrate that FGT’s claim—that faith alone, in a purely intellectual or one-time sense, guarantees salvation—does not align with Scripture. Faith is always accompanied by repentance, and this inseparability has been recognized historically as a core component of Christian orthodoxy.

4. Theological Analysis: The Problem of Separating Faith and Repentance

4.1. The Nature of True Faith

True saving faith, according to Scripture and historic theology, is both cognitive and relational. It involves knowledge of God’s truth, trust in Christ’s redemptive work, and submission to God’s authority. New Testament scholar Thomas Schreiner synthesizes the church fathers on this, “They gladly affirmed that salvation was of the Lord. They also, in line with the Pauline witness, confessed that salvation was by faith instead of by works. At the same time they concluded that good works were necessary for final salvation. These affirmations need not be seen as contradictory.”[19]

In contrast, FGT emphasizes intellectual assent or a singular moment of belief as sufficient for eternal security. By divorcing faith from repentance, FGT misrepresents the biblical nature of faith, creating the possibility of a saving faith that is empty or dead.

4.2. The Risk of False Assurance

One of the most significant pastoral dangers posed by FGT is the illusion of guaranteed salvation despite a life devoid of repentance or obedience.20 Individuals may assume they are saved based solely on a historical (even momentary) profession of faith, without any ongoing evidence of spiritual growth or transformation.[21]

Scripture repeatedly warns against such superficial faith. Jesus cautions that, “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven.” (Matt 7:21)

James similarly emphasizes that faith without works is dead (James 2:26). When faith is divorced from life change, as in FGT, professors[22] are susceptible to false assurance, mistakenly equating mere intellectual assent with salvation. FGT goes so far as to say that those who abandon the faith are still saved! Bob Wilkin and Ken Yates, leaders in FGT said “If someone believed in Jesus for eternal life—even if they later throw away or abandon their faith—they are still saved. Eternal life is eternal.”[23] This has mammoth implications for it communicates to those without communion with Christ (including atheists!) that if they prayed a prayer of salvation sometime in their lives, that they are eternally secure.[24] They communicate to those who deny the gospel (even though they prayed a prayer as a five year old at a VBS, or who profess faith but happily live in an adulterous relationship) that they are saved from God’s wrath.[25] Therefore, their theology in these cases essentially tells people that as long as they meant that prayer at some point in their life, even if they no longer mean it, they are eternally secure. This is possibly the greatest error in the FGT system.

4.3. Powerless Grace

Advocates of FGT maintain that saving faith is a simple act of believing in Jesus for eternal life, and that any change in life, while desirable, is not a necessary or inevitable result of that faith. They seek to preserve the freeness of the gospel by keeping repentance—especially in the sense of turning from sin—separate from the condition of salvation. In their view, grace saves apart from repentance (which they call a work), and moral transformation belongs in the realm of discipleship, not justification.[26] While this concern to protect grace from works-righteousness is understandable, it results in a conception of grace that falls short of the biblical witness. In Scripture, grace is not merely God’s favorable disposition toward sinners; it is his active power that rescues, renews, and reorients the heart toward himself (Eph 2:8–10; Titus 2:11–14). By allowing for a form of “salvation” in which the sinner may remain unchanged, the FGT position presents a grace that is cheap because it requires no surrender of the heart, valueless because it produces no true holiness, and powerless because it does not free from sin’s dominion.

In this framework, whatever transformation occurs after faith is understood as the result of a believer’s voluntary effort rather than the inevitable fruit of God’s Spirit at work in the repentant believer (Phil 2:12–13). This shifts the decisive cause of holiness from God’s sovereign work to human will. The gospel becomes reduced to a legal transaction that secures a heavenly future but may leave the present life untouched. Scripture, however, portrays grace as saving “completely” (Heb 7:25, NIV)—not only pardoning sin but breaking its power and producing new obedience.[27] Grace that does not transform is not the biblical grace of Christ; it is a diminished substitute that promises the benefits of salvation without delivering the reality.

4.4. Recap

Separating faith from repentance creates a theological system that:

1. Misrepresents biblical faith as purely cognitive.

2. Generates false assurance divorced from life transformation.

3. Makes grace powerless to transform lives.

Faith and repentance are two sides of the same coin. Faith, while entirely a gift of God’s grace, always results in a life reoriented toward God. Assurance, therefore, is not abstract but observable in the life of the believer, creating both confidence and spiritual accountability.

5. Answering Common FGT Objections

While FGT affirms salvation by grace through faith alone, it often resists identifying repentance as an essential aspect of saving faith. Below are common objections and biblical responses.

5.1. Faith alone is the sole requirement for eternal life, and adding repentance makes the gospel a works-based message.

FGT insists that requiring repentance as part of the gospel undermines the freeness of grace. They define repentance as a human work incompatible with salvation by grace alone through faith alone.

Response: Biblical repentance is not a meritorious work that earns salvation—it is the God-enabled turning of the heart toward Christ in faith. Scripture never presents repentance as something added to faith but as an inseparable aspect of saving faith itself (Acts 20:21; 26:20). Repentance is not about earning God’s favor; it is the Spirit’s gift that accompanies genuine trust in Christ, expressing itself in a turning from sin to God (Acts 11:18; 2 Tim. 2:25–26). To divorce repentance from faith is to redefine both terms in ways foreign to the apostolic gospel.

5.2. Repentance means only a change of mind, not turning from sin.

Repentance is merely a change of mind. FGT teaches that metanoia in the New Testament refers to an intellectual acknowledgment of Christ or agreement with the gospel, not a turning from sin. Eternal life depends solely on faith in Christ, and any ethical or behavioral reorientation is considered a separate issue, relevant to discipleship.

Response: In the New Testament, metanoia carries more than the sense of a mere change of mind. It describes a reorientation of life toward God and away from sin. Genuine saving faith always includes this turning—trusting Christ is inseparable from turning from sin. Repentance is not an optional add-on or a later stage of discipleship; it is part of what it means to truly believe.

5.3. The Gospel of John, written to bring people to faith, never mentions repentance.

FGT appeals to John’s Gospel as the model evangelistic book, noting that it calls people to “believe” nearly 100 times but never once commands them to repent. They conclude that repentance is unnecessary for eternal life.

Response: John’s emphasis on believing does not exclude the reality of repentance—it assumes it.[28] Belief, as John presents it, is never mere mental assent but a wholehearted trust that involves coming to the light and abandoning darkness (John 3:19–21). Jesus’ call to be “born again” (John 3:3) entails a radical transformation, which in other biblical contexts is described as repentance. When the Samaritan woman believed, she left her life of sin (John 4:28–29); the healed paralytic is told to “sin no more” (John 5:14); when the man born blind believed, he confessed Christ publicly (John 9:38). Jesus says “Whoever loves his life loses it, and whoever hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life. If anyone serves me, he must follow me…” (John 12:25-26). Jesus essentially says eternal life is connected with change of loves. Love for Jesus replaces love for self. The absence of the explicit term “repentance” does not indicate absence of its reality, just as the absence of the term “faith” in some evangelistic sermons (e.g., Acts 17:30–31) does not remove the necessity of faith.

We must not build our doctrine on an argument from silence in a single book but on the plenary teaching of Scripture, which consistently unites repentance and faith in the gospel call (e.g. Luke 24:46–47; Acts 2:38; 17:30–31).[29]

5.4. Calling unbelievers to repent confuses the gospel with discipleship.

FGT holds that repentance belongs to the realm of following Jesus after conversion, not to the initial reception of eternal life. They argue that including repentance in the gospel call burdens unbelievers with discipleship demands before they are even saved.

Response: Jesus and the apostles made no such separation in their preaching. Christ began his ministry with “Repent and believe in the gospel” (Mark 1:15) and told would-be followers to count the cost (Luke 14:25–33). Peter’s Pentecost sermon to unbelievers included the command to “repent” for the forgiveness of sins (Acts 2:38). The call to turn from sin and self to God in Christ is not an advanced stage of Christian growth—it is the very essence of initial saving faith. Discipleship begins at conversion.

5.5. Linking repentance to faith front-loads the gospel.

FGT fears requiring repentance will cause people to think they must reform their life before believing.

Response: Biblical repentance is not self-reformation prior to faith; it is the faith-response itself. A sinner does not first make himself worthy—he turns to Christ in the very act of trusting him to save. The prodigal son “came to himself” and returned to the father as he was (Luke 15:17–20). Repentance is not cleaning oneself up to be accepted but fleeing to the only one who can cleanse.

5.6. Repentance is good and necessary but separate from the call to faith.

FGT teaches that all people ought to repent, but they restrict repentance to a post-conversion or discipleship category. In their view, repentance relates to fellowship with God, spiritual growth, or avoiding temporal discipline—not to receiving eternal life. The gospel call to unbelievers, they argue, is solely to believe in Jesus for everlasting life, without reference to turning from sin.

Response: The apostolic preaching unites repentance and faith in the same gospel call. Paul testified that he proclaimed to “both Jews and Greeks… repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ” (Acts 20:21). Likewise, when addressing unbelievers, he declared that God “commands all people everywhere to repent” in view of the coming judgment (Acts 17:30–31). The New Testament does not present repentance as an optional follow-up to belief but as the heart-orientation of turning to Christ in faith. By separating repentance from the gospel, FGT allows for people to be saved who never repent of their sin.

5.7. Assurance comes only from Christ’s promise, not from fruit.

FGT insists that examining works for assurance undermines confidence in Christ alone.

Response: Scripture grounds assurance both in Christ’s finished work (objective) and in the Spirit’s fruit in the believer’s life (subjective). John writes, “By this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments” (1 John 2:3). The Apostle Paul tells us that we are to “work out your own salvation with fear and trembling” (Phil 2:12).[30] Also, Christians are called to “Examine yourselves, to see whether you are in the faith” (2 Cor 14:5). This is not shifting trust to works but recognizing the Spirit’s transforming presence as evidence of genuine faith.

5.8. Repentance as Part of Salvation Encourages Judgmentalism

Tying repentance to salvation risks making Christians judgmental, constantly evaluating whether others are truly saved based on their behavior. This could undermine assurance and make salvation appear dependent on works rather than Christ’s promise of eternal life by faith alone.

Response: It is true that Scripture warns against hypocritical judgment with a condemning spirit. Jesus says, “Judge not, that you be not judged” (Matt 7:1). Yet in context, he calls us to remove the log from our own eye “then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye” (Matt 7:5). Far from banning all judgment, Jesus commands a righteous kind of judgment that is humble, self-aware, and restorative. Likewise, Paul writes, “For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge? God judges those outside” (1 Cor 5:12–13). Repentance plays a key role in this discernment: it is not the ground of salvation, but the fruit of genuine faith. To affirm a profession of faith while ignoring a lifestyle of unrepentance is to confuse grace with license. True grace produces repentance and obedience as its fruit (Titus 2:11–12). Therefore, requiring repentance does not foster judgmentalism but ensures that the church exercises righteous judgment, safeguards its witness, and lovingly affirms the integrity of genuine faith.

6. Defense of Orthodox Free Grace[31]

6.1. Salvation Is Free, Yet Transformative

Historic Christianity affirms that salvation is entirely by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone (Eph 2:8–9). This grace is undeserved, unmerited, and freely given by God. However, the grace that saves is never alone. Rather, it transforms the believer, producing repentance, obedience, and sanctification.

Titus 2:11–14 states:

For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, training us to renounce ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age, waiting for our blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works.

Here, grace is described as active and instructive, not passive. God’s gift of salvation is accompanied by training, purifying, and motivating the believer toward holiness. Orthodox soteriology recognizes that faith necessarily includes a turning away from sin and toward God—a turning that is both inward (repentance of heart) and outward (obedience in life).

6.2. Faith and Repentance Are Two Sides of the Same Coin

As established in the Biblical Evidence section, passages such as Mark 1:15, Acts 20:21, James 2:14–26, and 1 John 2:3–6 consistently link faith and repentance.

6.3. Biblical and Pastoral Implications

1. Faith and Repentance Are Evidential — Assurance is grounded in God’s promises and confirmed by evidence in the believer’s life (1 John 2:3–6).

2. Transformative Grace Guards Against Legalism and Complacency — Grace is free, but it calls believers to action. It is neither coercive nor passive; it produces repentance and obedience naturally.

3. Pastoral Responsibility — Pastors must encourage both assurance and obedience. FGT’s model risks neglecting the pastoral call to nurture life transformation alongside the free gift of salvation.[32]

By maintaining both the freeness of grace and its transformative power, the historic church preserves the biblical gospel in its fullness, while offering true, sustainable assurance to believers.

6.4. Recap

Historic soteriology can be summarized as follows:

1. Salvation is free — entirely a work of God’s grace through faith.

2. Faith is always transformative — producing repentance, obedience, and good works.

3. Assurance is rooted in God’s promises and evident in the believer’s life — not in a mere intellectual or historical act of belief.

This stands in contrast to FGT, which emphasizes freeness while minimizing the transformative aspects of faith. By integrating both biblical truth and historic orthodoxy, the Christian church safeguards the integrity of the gospel, ensuring that salvation is free, yet never cheap.

7. Pastoral Applications

The theological distinctions between FGT and historic orthodoxy have significant implications for pastoral ministry, discipleship, and Christian formation. Understanding these implications ensures that believers are both assured and accountable, reflecting the fullness of God’s grace.

7.1. Preaching the Gospel

Pastors must proclaim the gospel in a way that emphasizes both the freeness of salvation and the necessity of faith that transforms. While FGT stresses freeness, historic orthodoxy maintains that true faith cannot exist apart from repentance and life transformation (Mark 1:15; Acts 20:21). Preaching should invite listeners to trust Christ fully, while also turning from sin, illustrating that God’s grace is both free and active.

7.2. Encouraging True Assurance

Assurance of salvation is central to the believer’s confidence and spiritual growth. True assurance rests not on a single intellectual act but on God’s promises confirmed in a life of faith and obedience (1 John 2:3–6). Pastors should help believers evaluate their faith by examining evidence of transformation, guiding them away from the false security promoted by FGT.

7.3. Discipleship and Spiritual Formation

Discipleship involves nurturing faith that bears fruit. By emphasizing the inseparability of faith and repentance, pastors can cultivate spiritual disciplines, obedience, and holiness. This ensures that grace leads to lifelong growth, not complacency or moral stagnation.

7.4. Evangelism and Clarity

Evangelism must convey that salvation is wholly by grace while calling for repentance and trust in Christ. Misrepresenting faith as mere belief, as FGT sometimes does, can lead to confusion or superficial conversions. Historical orthodoxy ensures that the gospel call invites both trust and transformation.

8. Conclusion

FGT is a recent reinterpretation of salvation, separating faith from repentance and emphasizing assurance based solely on intellectual belief. While its proponents adopt the language of “free grace,” their theology departs from the historic teaching of the Christian church and the consistent witness of Scripture.

The Bible clearly presents faith and repentance as inseparable, with genuine faith producing life transformation, obedience, and evidence of God’s work in the believer’s life (Mark 1:15; Acts 20:21; James 2:14–26; 1 John 2:3–6). Historic orthodoxy affirms that salvation is truly free, yet it is never inactive. God’s grace brings life change, calling believers to turn from sin, trust Christ fully, and bear fruit in obedience.

For the pastor, teacher, and church leader, this understanding provides a foundation for preaching, discipleship, and pastoral care that protects believers from false assurance while nurturing a deep, transformative relationship with Christ. God’s grace is free, but it is also powerful—transforming hearts, producing holiness, and securing eternal life.

As the church proclaims the gospel faithfully, it must hold in tension the freeness of grace and the necessity of faith that works through love, ensuring that believers are secure, transformed, and growing in Christ.

Footnotes

[1] Free Grace Theology will be referred to as FGT for the rest of this paper.

[2] Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians, Ch.7, https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1010.htm, accessed 08/18/2025.

[3] Ignatius of Antioch, The Epistle of Ignatius to the Smyrnaeans, Ch.5, https://www.catholica.com/epistle-of-ignatius-to-the-smyrnaeans/index.html, accessed 08/18/2025.

[4] Justin Martyr, First Apology, Ch.16, https://biblehub.com/library/richardson/early_christian_fathers/the_first_apology_of_justin.htm, accessed 08/18/2025.

[5] Tertullian, On Repentance, Ch.9, https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0320.htm, accessed 08/18/2025.

[6] Gregory the Great, The Book of Pastoral Rule, III.30, Admonition 31. https://ia902307.us.archive.org/13/items/Elijah_Elisha/St.%20Gregory%20the%20Great%20-%20The%20Book%20of%20the%20Pastoral%20Rule.pdf accessed 08/18/2025.

[7] Martin Luther, Commentary on Galatians (Grand Rapids: Kregel Classics, 1979) 314.

[8] Westminster Confession of Faith, Ch. 11, Sec. 2.

[9] London Baptist Confession (1689), Ch. 16, Sec. 2.

[10] John Wesley, Sermon 35,https://wesley.nnu.edu/john-wesley/the-sermons-of-john-wesley-1872-edition/sermon-35-the-law-established-through-faith-discourse-one/ accessed 08/18/2025.

[11] Billy Graham, “Wit & Wisdom: Grace of God,” 12/09/2015, https://billygrahamlibrary.org/wit-wisdom-grace-of-god/ accessed 8/13/2025. Some FGT may argue that this a Calvinist understanding of salvation. Billy Graham is listed here because he was not Calvinist to illustrate that this is the understanding of Evangelical theology.

[12] Zane C. Hodges, Absolutely Free! A Biblical Reply to Lordship Salvation (Dallas: Redencion Viva, 1989).

[13] See also Wayne A. Grudem, “Free Grace” Theology: 5 Ways It Diminishes the Gospel (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2016). Michael Horton, Christless Christianity: The Alternative Gospel of the American Church (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2008). R. C. Sproul, Faith Alone: The Evangelical Doctrine of Justification (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1995). Thomas R. Schreiner and Ardel B. Caneday, The Race Set Before Us: A Biblical Theology of Perseverance and Assurance (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2001).

[14] See Athanasius, On the Incarnation, §5, 9. Augustine, On the Grace of Christ and Original Sin, I.24. Leo the Great, Letter to the Bishop of Aquileia (Letter 1), II.3.

[15] All Scripture references are from the ESV unless otherwise stated. Mark 1:15 is representative of other passages in the gospel where Jesus links faith and repentance together. See also: Matt 4:7; Luke 5:32; 11:32; 13:3; 15:3-7, 8-10; 17:34; 24:46-47.

[16] According to BDAG (the gold-standard academic Greek lexicon), there are two definitions given for metanoia. The first is “change of mind,” but there are no biblical uses mentioned. The second definition is “feel remorse, repent, be converted.” There are numerous New Testament uses of metanoia fitting this definition attested to. S.v. “μετανοέω,” Arndt, William, Frederick W. Danker, Walter Bauer, and F. Wilbur Gingrich. in A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000.

[17] See above James 2:19-20.

[18] In Romans 1:17, the phrase “from faith for faith” can be translated as “beginning and ending in faith,” see the footnote in the ESV version. The NIV renders this as “by faith from first to last.”

[19] Thomas Schreiner, Faith Alone—The Doctrine of Justification: What the Reformers Taught … and Why It Still Matters (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2015), 23.

[20] Zane Hodges, Absolutely Free: A Biblical Reply to Lordship Salvation, 2nd ed. (Corinth, TX: Grace Evangelical Society, 1989, 2014) 101.

[21] Bob Nyberg, “A History of Free Grace,” (2021), https://www.gracelife.org/resources/grr/?id=31, accessed 08/18/2025.

[22] Those who profess faith.

[23] Bob Wilkin and Ken Yates, “If You Throw Away or Abandon Your Faith, How Can You Still Be Saved?” 2/7/2023, https://faithalone.org/radio/if-you-throw-away-or-abandon-your-faith-how-can-you-still-be-saved/, accessed 8/14/2025.

[24] FGT proponents would also say that such people ought to repent and live for the Lord so that they have eternal rewards in heaven. However, the error here is still grave.

[25] There are plenty of Scriptures that warn that those who practice such things will not inherit the Kingdom. See 1 Cor 6:9-10; Gal 5:19-21; Eph 5:5.

[26] Hodges, Absolutely Free, 82.

[27] The word in Hebrews 7:25 translated as “completely” in the NIV, is translated as “to the uttermost” in the ESV, and “forever” in the NASB. All these senses are carried by the Greek word in this passage. Therefore, to save completely and forever is in view here which has implications for the life of the saved person here and now. For more on this see: David L. Allen, Hebrews, NAC (Nashville: B & H Publishing Group, 2010), 429, and Thomas R. Schreiner, Hebrews, EBTC (Bellingham: Lexham Press, 2021), 233.

[28] I am appreciative of Wayne Grudem’s insights here. See Wayne A. Grudem, “Free Grace” Theology: 5 Ways It Diminishes the Gospel (Wheaton: Crossway, 2016), 48-54.

[29] Similarly, possibly the most evangelistic book, the book of Acts, never mentions the love of God. If a theology for evangelism were derived strictly from Acts (ignoring the rest of Scripture), then the conclusion (using the logic above with reference to repentance and John’s gospel) would be that the love of God has no part in evangelism. This is further evidence that we must have the whole counsel of God (Acts 20:27).

[30] The gospel beauty of this is found in the following verse “for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Phil 2:13). This means that part of our salvation is to work out what God has worked in. In other words, even our works are God ordained responses to God, but this passage implies that these responses accompany a saving faith.

[31] Orthodox is in reference to “right doctrine.” This is not a reference to the Greek or Russian Orthodox Church.

[32] A salvation that is separated from the process of being conformed into the image of Christ essentially severs justification from sanctification. In other words, sanctification becomes a second type salvation (or at least a second tier salvation). If salvation is merely about going to heaven, then it begs the question: How is this eternal life? Jesus said “this is eternal life, that they know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent” (John 17:3). If eternal life is about knowing the triune God, and knowing him is to be in relationship with him, then how can there be salvation for those who do not walk with him? Such a gospel is both a powerless gospel (because it affects no change) and a Christ-less gospel (because there is no relationship with Christ).

Up Next
From this Author: Matt Kottman
December 15, 2025 • 11 Minute Read
Singing Without Gaps
Introduction Congregational singing is one of the most formative practices in the life of the church. Long before many Christians can clearly explain doctrine, they learn what to believe by what they sing.[1] Scripture itself presents singing as a means by which truth is remembered, rehearsed, and passed on from one generation to the next (Deut 31:19–21; Ps 145:4). For this reason, the question is not simply whether a song feels sincere or emotionally moving, but whether it clearly communicates truth. In recent years, many often-used worship songs function as what I am calling fill-in-the-gap songs—songs that allude to God’s work without clearly naming it, assuming the worshiper will supply the meaning that Scripture ordinarily speaks plainly. This is not a rejection of contemporary music, nor a criticism of sincere worshipers. It is a call to think carefully and lovingly about what our singing is doing to us over time. In Scripture, the gospel is not only the message by which we enter the Christian life, but the truth by which we continue to live, grow, repent, hope, and endure (Rom 1:16–17; Gal 2:20; Col 2:6–7). What Are “Fill-in-the-Gap Songs”? By fill-in-the-gap songs, I mean songs that: Speak of gratitude, freedom, victory, or devotion Use familiar Christian language But do not clearly state what God has done, how he has done it, or why it matters These songs often include phrases like: “For all that you’ve done” “You made a way” “I’m free” “I’m grateful” All of these statements are true. The concern is that they are left undefined. The song relies on the worshiper to mentally supply the cross, forgiveness of sin, Christ’s sacrifice, and resurrection hope. Scripture models a different pattern. Biblical praise repeatedly names the acts of God rather than assuming them (Ps 105:1–5; Ps 136; Rev 5:9–10). Why the Gaps Matter 1. Singing Is One Way We Learn the Faith The New Testament explicitly connects congregational singing with instruction and growth: “Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom, singing…” (Col 3:16) Similarly, “Addressing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs…” (Eph 5:19) When the church sings, it is not only speaking to God; it is also teaching one another. Over time, what we sing shapes how we understand God, salvation, and the Christian life. This includes not only how we understand conversion, but how we understand daily repentance, obedience, suffering, assurance, and growth. If the gospel is assumed rather than named, believers may begin the Christian life grounded in Christ’s work, yet slowly drift toward living by memory, emotion, or effort rather than by faith in what Christ has accomplished (Gal 3:1-3). Singing that clearly proclaims Christ’s saving work and helps believers continue to live by grace rather than by feelings or performance. If our songs regularly express devotion without clearly naming God’s saving work, we risk forming warm feelings without clear understanding (Rom 10:17). 2. Gratitude Needs a Clear Reason In Scripture, thanksgiving is never vague. Gratitude always flows from something God has done: “Give thanks to the Lord… for he has redeemed” (Ps 107:1–2) “I give thanks… because of the grace of God given you in Christ Jesus” (1 Cor 1:4) “Thanks be to God for his inexpressible gift!” (2 Cor 9:15) Biblical gratitude is anchored in redemption clearly stated. When gratitude is detached from those reasons, it becomes fragile. In seasons of suffering, worshipers need songs that remind them not only that God is worthy, but why hope remains (Lam 3:21–23; Rom 8:31–39). 3. We Sing for Everyone, Not Just the Mature When the church gathers, it sings for: The longtime believer and the new Christian The confident and the doubting The joyful and the grieving Scripture repeatedly emphasizes clarity for the sake of the whole community. God commands truth to be taught plainly and repeatedly (Deut 6:6–7), and Paul insists that what happens in gathered worship should be understandable so that all may be built up (1 Cor 14:12, 26). Congregational songs should not require advanced theological knowledge to be understood. They should carry the truth clearly, especially for the weakest among us. They should also carry truth clearly to the non-believer. If those who are less spiritually mature may unintentionally fill in the gaps with a deficient understanding of the gospel, what about those who do not yet believe at all? When songs leave their meaning undefined, non-Christians may be able to sing along comfortably, supplying their own interpretations of gratitude, freedom, or hope. In that case, the song can be affirmed without the gospel ever being encountered. By contrast, songs that clearly and explicitly name the gospel[2] do not merely invite participation; they bear witness. They direct the non-Christian not toward personal experience or vague spirituality, but toward the saving work of Christ himself (1 Cor 14:24–25). This Is Not About Old Versus New Scripture commands God’s people to sing new songs (Ps 96:1; 149:1). God has always given his people fresh expressions of praise, and he continues to do so today. Many modern worship songs are biblically faithful, Christ-centered, and deeply helpful for congregational worship. The issue is not age, style, or sound. The issue is clarity. What Scripture consistently emphasizes is truthfulness and intelligibility, not musical era (Ps 33:3–4). A Case Study: Two Modern Songs A Fill-in-the-Gap Example: Gratitude (Brandon Lake) Gratitude is one of the most sung worship songs in churches across the United States this year, regularly appearing near the top of the CCLI charts. This makes it an important example, not because it is obscure, but because it exemplifies what is shaping what many congregations sing on Sunday. The song is sincere and God-directed. It centers on the worshiper’s sense of not having enough words or strength to properly thank God. That posture of humility is not unbiblical (Ps 116:12). However, the song’s focus remains largely on the worshiper’s response: Lifting hands Bowing down Expressing gratitude What the song does not clearly articulate is the reason for that gratitude. Scripture, by contrast, consistently ties praise to clearly named redemption: “Worthy are you… for you were slain, and by your blood you ransomed people for God” (Rev 5:9). In Gratitude, redemption is assumed rather than stated. Even when the worshiper does know the gospel, the song does not require that knowledge to be actively remembered or consciously applied to what is being sung. The language of gratitude may be attached, without intention, to personal experiences, emotions, or recent blessings rather than to the saving work of Christ himself. Scripture repeatedly warns God’s people not merely against ignorance, but against forgetfulness. “Bless the Lord, O my soul, and forget not all his benefits” (Ps 103:2). Israel did not forget that the Lord existed; they forgot what he had done (Ps 106:7). The New Testament issues the same warning, urging believers to pay close attention lest they drift away from what they have heard (Heb 2:1) and cautioning against beginning with Christ’s work but subtly shifting toward another ground of confidence (Gal 3:1–3). A simple illustration may help. Imagine thanking someone warmly for rescuing you, but never mentioning from what you were rescued. Over time, the gratitude may remain sincere, but the rescue itself fades from view. Eventually, thankfulness may attach itself to how safe you feel now, rather than to the costly act that made safety possible. In the same way, when songs do not clearly name Christ’s saving work, gratitude can quietly drift from being anchored in the cross to being shaped by mood, circumstance, or perceived closeness to God. This does not mean the worshiper is insincere. It means the song leaves room for gratitude to become subjective rather than anchored, shaped more by experience than by the gospel. Our songs should actively draw what we know about the gospel into our worship, anchoring gratitude in what God has done rather than leaving it vulnerable to forgetfulness or drift. A Clear Modern Contrast: In Christ Alone (Keith Getty / Stuart Townend) In Christ Alone is also a modern song, written in our lifetime,[3] yet it follows a different and more biblically shaped pattern. Rather than beginning with the worshiper’s response, the song begins with what is true outside of us, namely who Christ is and what he has done. The song walks the church through the story of redemption in clear, concrete language: Christ’s incarnation (John 1:14) His sinless life (Heb 4:15) His substitutionary death for sinners (Isa 53:5–6; Rom 3:24–26) His resurrection and victory over death (1 Cor 15:3–4) The worshiper’s secure hope and assurance in him (Rom 8:1, 38–39) By doing this, the song anchors worship in realities that do not change with the worshiper’s emotions, circumstances, or spiritual condition. Before the worshiper is invited to feel confidence, gratitude, or hope, the song tells us why such confidence is warranted. This guards the church from subjectivism in several ways: First, the song places the weight of faith on Christ’s finished work, not on the worshiper’s present experience. Assurance is grounded not in how near God feels, but in what Christ has accomplished once for all (Heb 10:10–14). Second, the song gives the congregation shared, public language that shapes understanding together. Salvation is not left to private interpretation or personal projection. The gospel is clearly stated and corporately confessed (1 Cor 15:1–4). Third, the song trains worshipers to interpret their lives through the gospel, rather than interpreting the gospel through their lives. Because the song begins with Christ and ends with unshakeable hope, it teaches worshipers to measure feelings and circumstances against what God has done, not the other way around (Rom 8:32). Finally, In Christ Alone gives words for worship when personal experience offers little help. In seasons of suffering, doubt, or dryness, the worshiper may struggle to generate gratitude from within. A song anchored in objective truth allows the church to sing what is true even when it is hard to feel (Ps 42:5; Hab 3:17–19). In this way, the song does not merely express faith; it forms and protects it, guarding worship from drifting toward subjectivism and keeping praise anchored in the unchanging gospel. What I Am Encouraging (and What I Am Not) I am not saying: Every song must say everything (John 21:25) Every modern song is unhelpful Emotion has no place in worship (Ps 98:4) I am saying: The church’s regular singing should clearly proclaim the gospel (1 Cor 15:1–4) Songs of response should grow out of songs that clearly state God’s saving work (Ps 40:3) Gratitude should be built on named redemption, not assumed understanding (Ps 103:2–4) A Simple Question to Ask A practical question for evaluating congregational songs is this: If someone sang this song for a year, would they understand the gospel more clearly or simply know that they feel grateful? Scripture repeatedly urges God’s people not to forget what he has done (Ps 78:4–7). Our songs should help us remember. Conclusion The church does not sing only to express what we feel, but to remind ourselves of what is true. Songs that clearly name God’s saving work help worshipers remain anchored when emotions are strong and when they are weak (Heb 2:1). They do so by continually returning the church to the gospel as the source not only of forgiveness, but of daily faith, obedience, repentance, and hope. The goal is not to sing fewer songs of gratitude, but to sing gratitude that knows exactly what it is grateful for. Not to reject what is new, but to ensure that what we sing can carry the full weight of biblical faith across generations. Fill-in-the-gap songs assume the gospel. The church’s songs should clearly tell the gospel.Download this article Footnotes [1] Several years ago, on a flight, I happened to sit next to Stuart Townend (co-author of In Christ Alone and How Deep the Father’s Love for Us). I asked him why he writes modern hymns. He said the church needs better theology and therefore the church needs better songs. People do not go home singing the points of a sermon, but they will go home singing the verses of a song. [2] The gospel is the announcement that Jesus Christ has accomplished everything necessary for our salvation through his life, death, and resurrection, and that this same grace now shapes how we live, suffer, love, work, repent, worship, and persevere until he makes all things new. It is about more than just ‘getting saved,’ but about how Christ’s work applies that salvation to every facet of life. [3] This wasn’t during the lifetime of every reader, © 2001 Thankyou Music, Keith Getty / Stuart Townend.
August 18, 2025 • 38 Minute Read
Free Yet Transforming
1. Introduction In the ongoing struggle to faithfully articulate the heart of the Christian gospel, evangelical churches today face recurring challenges from theological systems that risk distorting the message of salvation by grace through faith. One significant movement in this arena is “Free Grace Theology” (FGT),[1] which, in its quest to protect the doctrine of sola fide ("faith alone"), has redefined saving faith as a mere act of intellectual assent, separated from repentance, obedience, and transformation. While FGT affirms that salvation is exclusively the gift of God, received through faith apart from any works, it interprets biblical faith in such a narrow manner that it routinely severs justification from sanctification, and assurance from perseverance in the Christian life. This paper seeks to offer a comprehensive historical, biblical, and pastoral critique of FGT. With a spirit of charitable concern, and a commitment to the clarity and fullness of the gospel, the following analysis argues that the witness of Scripture and the testimony of historic Christianity both affirm that authentic faith in Christ is inseparably linked to repentance, transformation, and obedience—in other words, that while faith alone justifies, justifying faith is never alone. This paper will examine FGT in terms of its definition, development, theological claims, exegetical arguments, and practical consequences, seeking to uphold the historic Protestant and biblical account of salvation which, far from undermining grace, vindicates it by showing that grace not only pardons but also transforms. As this paper will argue, FGT is a departure from an orthodox view of salvation, however this does not mean that those who hold this view, and are repenting of sin and hoping in Christ are not saved. There are many faithful Christians who hold this view and we should treat them as brothers and sisters in Christ. However, this in no way validates FGT. It does however call us to engage and discuss these issues with Christian charity. For if you have all knowledge and all faith but have not love, you are nothing (1 Cor 13:2). 2. Historical Context 2.1. The Development of Lordship Salvation The Lordship Salvation movement emphasizes that saving faith in Christ is never abstract or merely intellectual but involves submission to Christ as Lord resulting in repentance from sin. Though the term “Lordship Salvation” gained widespread attention in the 1980s, the concept itself is deeply rooted in historic theology. Even in the earliest centuries of the church, leaders connected faith and repentance inseparably. Clement of Rome (c. 35 – c. 99 AD) wrote: Let us attend to what is good, pleasing, and acceptable in the sight of Him who formed us. Let us look steadfastly to the blood of Christ, and see how precious that blood is to God which, having been shed for our salvation, has set the grace of repentance before the whole world… from generation to generation, the Lord has granted a place of repentance to all such as would be converted unto Him.[2] Ignatius of Antioch (c. 35 – c. 108 AD) called believers to repent and turn to a true faith in Christ’s passion, implying that without repentance, faith is not genuine.[3] Justin Martyr (c. 100 – c. 165 AD) stated, “Those who are found not living as he taught should know that they are not really Christians, even if his teachings are on their lips, for he said that not those who merely profess but those who also do the works will be saved.”[4] Tertullian (c. 155 – c. 240 AD) likewise saw repentance as integral to forgiveness, “we confess our sins to the Lord… of confession repentance is born; by repentance God is appeased.”[5] Gregory the Great (c. 540-604 AD) wrote, “For whosoever mourns past transgressions, yet forsakes them not ... subjects himself to the penalty of more grievous sin They cleanse themselves in vain by their weeping, if they wickedly defile themselves in their living.”[6] The Reformers consistently taught that genuine faith produces repentance and obedience as evidence of salvation. Martin Luther’s comments in his Galatians commentary yield insight. Galatians 5:6 reads, “For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision counts for anything, but only faith working through love.” Luther points out that a true faith is a working faith. He wrote, “[H]e that will be a true Christian, must be a true believer. Now he believeth not truly, if works and charity [love] follow not faith….”[7] Similarly, confessional documents such as the Westminster Confession of Faith affirm that faith always involves a turning from sin: “Faith, thus receiving and resting on Christ and His righteousness, is the alone instrument of justification: yet it is not alone in the person justified, but is ever accompanied with all other saving graces, and is never without hope, love, and repentance.”[8] The London Baptist Confession of 1689 states, “These good works, done in obedience to God’s commandments, are the fruit and evidence of a true and living faith.”[9] Even the Arminian founder of the Methodist Church, John Wesley said, “We are justified without the works of the law, as any previous condition of justification; but they are an immediate fruit of that faith whereby we are justified. So that if good works do not follow our faith, even all inward and outward holiness, it is plain our faith is nothing worth; we are yet in our sins.”[10] Billy Graham put it this way, “Only as we bow in contrition, confession, and repentance at the foot of the Cross, can we find forgiveness.”[11] Historically, this understanding formed the consensus of orthodox Christianity: true faith is inseparable from repentance which results in life transformation. 2.2. The Emergence of Free Grace Theology FGT, by contrast, is a late twentieth-century development. The Grace Evangelical Society (GES), founded in 1986 by Robert Wilkin, and prominent figures such as Zane Hodges, sought to counter what they perceived as a legalistic distortion in Lordship Salvation.[12] Hodges and his colleagues argued that the gospel guarantees eternal life to anyone who believes, regardless of repentance, discipleship, or obedience. Key works like The Gospel Under Siege (1981) and Absolutely Free! (1989) explicitly articulate this position. FGT is therefore reactive in nature: it was formulated as a response to the Lordship Salvation emphasis popularized by John MacArthur’s The Gospel According to Jesus (1988) and other evangelical leaders who stressed the inseparability of faith and obedience.[13] FGT claims its view shows the “freeness of grace,” but it redefines that freeness in a way that deviates from historic orthodoxy, reducing it to intellectual assent, by removing repentance from it. The name “Free Grace Theology” is a name that its proponents came up with for themselves. One should not read the phrase free grace in the title and assume that other understandings of salvation are importing a merited grace idea. Free grace is what they see themselves as defending, however this paper will make clear that FGT fails to live up to its namesake. 2.3. Distinguishing FGT from Historic Orthodoxy It is important to recognize that FGT does not reject the freeness of God’s grace; rather, it reinterprets grace. Historic Christian theology affirms that salvation is a free gift of God, not merited by works (Eph. 2:8–9).[14] Yet, that grace is never inactive. Genuine grace inevitably produces repentance, good works, and obedience to God’s commands. The novelty of FGT lies not in its affirmation of free grace but in its separation of grace from repentance and the ongoing transformation of the believer’s life—a separation unsupported by Scripture and historic confessions. 3. Biblical Evidence for the Inseparability of Faith and Repentance 3.1. The Gospel Call Mark 1:15 “and saying, ‘The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel.’” (Mark 1:15) Jesus inaugurated his public ministry with a concise yet profound proclamation, “The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel” (Mark 1:15).[15] This verse immediately links repentance with faith as the response to the gospel. The command to “repent and believe” is not sequential in a purely chronological sense but relational and conceptual: true belief necessarily entails turning from sin and turning toward God. Jesus’ use of both terms together indicates that faith cannot exist in isolation; it is a holistic orientation of the heart and life toward God. The Greek word metanoia means to “feel remorse, repent, be converted.”[16] It is a reorientation of life. When combined with faith, it emphasizes that genuine trust in God produces an active rejection of sin and a life turned toward obedience. In other words, repentance is not an optional add-on to faith; it is an intrinsic aspect of faith in Christ. 3.2. Apostolic Teaching 3.2.1. Acts 14:15 “Men, why are you doing these things? We also are men, of like nature with you, and we bring you good news, that you should turn from these vain things to a living God, who made the heaven and the earth and the sea and all that is in them.” (Acts 14:15) In Lystra, Paul declares the gospel as a call to turn “from these vain things” to “a living God.” While the word “repentance” is not explicitly used, the concept is embedded in the language of turning. Here repentance is a transfer of trust—from dead idols to the living Creator. This illustrates why repentance and faith are inseparable: to repent is to redirect trust from one object to another. In biblical terms, repentance is faith forsaking one object and embracing another. 3.2.2. Acts 20:21 “testifying both to Jews and to Greeks of repentance toward God and of faith in our Lord Jesus Christ.” (Acts 20:21) The Apostle Paul summarizes his evangelistic mission as “…testifying both to Jews and Greeks of repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ” (Acts 20:21) Paul explicitly pairs repentance with faith, framing them as complementary responses to the gospel. The Greek construction of this phrase demonstrates that repentance is directed toward God and faith is directed toward Christ. This dual focus indicates the holistic nature of conversion: one turns from sin to God while simultaneously trusting in Christ for salvation. This pairing is elsewhere in the New Testament, particularly in the preaching of Peter (Acts 2:38) and John the Baptist (Matt 3:2), consistently presenting repentance and faith as inseparable dimensions of a biblical response to God’s call. 3.2.3. Acts 26:20 “but declared first to those in Damascus, then in Jerusalem and throughout all the region of Judea, and also to the Gentiles, that they should repent and turn to God, performing deeds in keeping with their repentance.” (Acts 26:20) As the gospel call was given both to Jews and Gentiles, everyone is called to repent and turn to God. To turn away from one thing is to turn to another. The act of repentance is also the act of turning to God. Both of these can be encapsulated in the concept of genuine faith. The text does not communicate repentance and turning to God as two separate and distinct things. This is clear in how the verse ends by reemphasizing genuine repentance. He is not speaking about repentance then turning to God as a separate concept, then returning again to repentance. There is more continuity in the argument than that. He is speaking of one thing which is a turning from sin which is (in the same act) a turning to God. One cannot turn to God if he is not simultaneously turning from sin. 3.3. Faith Manifested in Works 3.3.1. Matthew 7:17-20 “So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit. A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit. Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. Thus you will recognize them by their fruits.” (Matt 7:17-20) Jesus is speaking about false prophets in this passage, but he speaks about a general reality. We produce what we are. If a person has faith in Christ, meaning the Spirit of God dwells in him and he is a new creation, having a new heart (Rom 8:9; 2 Cor 5:17; Ezek 36:26), then he will bear fruit that is consistent with this new nature. Therefore, according to Jesus, it is not unreasonable to look at a person’s fruit/works for insight into whether that person is a genuine Christian. Some arguing against this would suggest that this expects perfect obedience. But the Scriptures are clear that we stumble in many ways (Jas 3:2). Our whole lives are lives of repentance and sanctification. 3.3.2. James 2:14–26 James 2:14–26 famously addresses the relationship between faith and works, “So also faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead” (Jas 2:17). James does not deny justification by faith; rather, he emphasizes that true faith inevitably produces good works (life change). Saving faith is never inactive—it manifests itself in obedience, love, and action. The rhetorical argument of James, “Was not Abraham our father justified by works when he offered his son Isaac?” (2:21), illustrates that faith and obedience are intimately linked. Abraham’s willingness to act was the evidence of his saving faith. 3.4. Grace Is not in Vain: 1 Corinthians 15:9–10 “For I am the least of the apostles, unworthy to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the church of God. But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace toward me was not in vain. On the contrary, I worked harder than any of them, though it was not I, but the grace of God that is with me.” (1 Cor 15:9–10) After defining the gospel and affirming its supremacy to the Corinthians (1 Cor 15:1–8), Paul turns to his own experience as living proof of its power. Once a persecutor of the church, he confesses, “his grace toward me was not in vain.” (1 Cor 15:10). If God’s grace had left Paul unchanged, it would have been empty and ineffective. Instead, that grace transformed him and energized his labor. In other words, saving grace is never without effect—it always produces change. 3.5. A Grace that Works: Ephesians 2:8–10 “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast. For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them.” (Eph 2:8–10) The Apostle Paul leaves no doubt that salvation is by grace. Yet Ephesians 2:8–10 gives the full picture. We are not saved by works, but by grace through a faith that works. We are not saved by works but for works. The conjunction “for” in verse 10 grounds the statement of verses 8–9: works do not save, rather that salvation itself creates us anew resulting in good works. Works are not the cause of salvation but its inevitable result. The same grace that saves also works within us to produce what pleases God. 3.6. Professing and Believing Are not the Same Thing 3.6.1. Titus 1:16 “They profess to know God, but they deny him by their works. They are detestable, disobedient, unfit for any good work.” (Tit 1:16) Titus is being warned that a profession of faith is only as good as the works that prove that profession. The belief that a person can be in Christ, professing to know God, but not having repented of his sins is categorically denied by the Apostle Paul. A true faith gives evidence of its existence. 3.6.2. James 2:19-20 “You believe that God is one; you do well. Even the demons believe—and shudder! Do you want to be shown, you foolish person, that faith apart from works is useless?” (Jas 2:19–20) Believing can have more than one meaning. A belief that merely acknowledges the truth of something is no different than the type of belief that demons have, and even the demons shudder! That is to say, they tremble before God. The point James is making in this text is that this kind of faith is of no value. Genuine faith brings with it evidence of that faith. He is not saying that we are saved by works, rather that works are the necessary result of faith. A true faith is a repenting faith. 3.7. Assurance Through Obedience 3.7.1. 1 John 2:3–6 “And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments. Whoever says “I know him” but does not keep his commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in him, but whoever keeps his word, in him truly the love of God is perfected. By this we may know that we are in him: whoever says he abides in him ought to walk in the same way in which he walked.” (1 Jn 2:3–6) The Apostle John reinforces the connection between faith and life transformation, “And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments. Whoever says “I know him” but does not keep his commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in him,” (1 John 2:3–4). John’s epistle underscores that genuine knowledge of God—saving faith—produces obedience. Faith is not merely an intellectual claim; it is relational and transformative.[17] The moral and spiritual fruit of obedience functions as both evidence and assurance of salvation. Those who claim belief without obedience may lack true faith, a concern that FGT underemphasizes by separating belief from life change. 3.7.2. Romans 1:16–17; 16:25–27 “For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith for faith, as it is written, “The righteous shall live by faith.” (Rom 1:16–17) “Now to him who is able to strengthen you according to my gospel and the preaching of Jesus Christ, according to the revelation of the mystery that was kept secret for long ages but has now been disclosed and through the prophetic writings has been made known to all nations, according to the command of the eternal God, to bring about the obedience of faith— to the only wise God be glory forevermore through Jesus Christ! Amen.” (Rom 16:25–27) The Apostle opens Romans with a declaration of the gospel’s surprising power: it is “the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes” (Rom 1:16). He immediately adds that “the righteousness of God is revealed from faith for faith, as it is written, ‘The righteous shall live by faith’” (Rom 1:17).[18] From the outset, Paul emphasizes that salvation is entirely by faith—faith that both saves and sustains the believer’s life. This, he says, is the gospel. When Paul closes the letter, he frames the gospel he has proclaimed from start to finish as producing “the obedience of faith” (Rom 16:25–26). Faith in the gospel inevitably issues in obedience. Where there is no obedience, there is no assurance that saving faith is present. Salvation is by grace through faith, but that faith is living—it produces repentance and grows a life of obedience. 3.8. Recap Across both the Gospels and the Epistles, the biblical witness consistently affirms: 1. Faith and repentance are inseparable — Conversion is one unified act of turning from sin to God and trusting in Christ. 2. The gospel call is holistic — The apostles consistently proclaim repentance toward God and faith in Christ as one response. 3. Saving grace always transforms — The grace that saves also re-creates, energizes, and produces a new life. 4. Works flow from salvation — Good works are the inevitable result of genuine faith, never its cause. 5. Empty profession is exposed — Claims to know God without accompanying change are rejected as false. 6. Obedience gives assurance — A life marked by “the obedience of faith” confirms that grace has been truly received. These passages collectively demonstrate that FGT’s claim—that faith alone, in a purely intellectual or one-time sense, guarantees salvation—does not align with Scripture. Faith is always accompanied by repentance, and this inseparability has been recognized historically as a core component of Christian orthodoxy. 4. Theological Analysis: The Problem of Separating Faith and Repentance 4.1. The Nature of True Faith True saving faith, according to Scripture and historic theology, is both cognitive and relational. It involves knowledge of God’s truth, trust in Christ’s redemptive work, and submission to God’s authority. New Testament scholar Thomas Schreiner synthesizes the church fathers on this, “They gladly affirmed that salvation was of the Lord. They also, in line with the Pauline witness, confessed that salvation was by faith instead of by works. At the same time they concluded that good works were necessary for final salvation. These affirmations need not be seen as contradictory.”[19] In contrast, FGT emphasizes intellectual assent or a singular moment of belief as sufficient for eternal security. By divorcing faith from repentance, FGT misrepresents the biblical nature of faith, creating the possibility of a saving faith that is empty or dead. 4.2. The Risk of False Assurance One of the most significant pastoral dangers posed by FGT is the illusion of guaranteed salvation despite a life devoid of repentance or obedience.20 Individuals may assume they are saved based solely on a historical (even momentary) profession of faith, without any ongoing evidence of spiritual growth or transformation.[21] Scripture repeatedly warns against such superficial faith. Jesus cautions that, “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven.” (Matt 7:21) James similarly emphasizes that faith without works is dead (James 2:26). When faith is divorced from life change, as in FGT, professors[22] are susceptible to false assurance, mistakenly equating mere intellectual assent with salvation. FGT goes so far as to say that those who abandon the faith are still saved! Bob Wilkin and Ken Yates, leaders in FGT said “If someone believed in Jesus for eternal life—even if they later throw away or abandon their faith—they are still saved. Eternal life is eternal.”[23] This has mammoth implications for it communicates to those without communion with Christ (including atheists!) that if they prayed a prayer of salvation sometime in their lives, that they are eternally secure.[24] They communicate to those who deny the gospel (even though they prayed a prayer as a five year old at a VBS, or who profess faith but happily live in an adulterous relationship) that they are saved from God’s wrath.[25] Therefore, their theology in these cases essentially tells people that as long as they meant that prayer at some point in their life, even if they no longer mean it, they are eternally secure. This is possibly the greatest error in the FGT system. 4.3. Powerless Grace Advocates of FGT maintain that saving faith is a simple act of believing in Jesus for eternal life, and that any change in life, while desirable, is not a necessary or inevitable result of that faith. They seek to preserve the freeness of the gospel by keeping repentance—especially in the sense of turning from sin—separate from the condition of salvation. In their view, grace saves apart from repentance (which they call a work), and moral transformation belongs in the realm of discipleship, not justification.[26] While this concern to protect grace from works-righteousness is understandable, it results in a conception of grace that falls short of the biblical witness. In Scripture, grace is not merely God’s favorable disposition toward sinners; it is his active power that rescues, renews, and reorients the heart toward himself (Eph 2:8–10; Titus 2:11–14). By allowing for a form of “salvation” in which the sinner may remain unchanged, the FGT position presents a grace that is cheap because it requires no surrender of the heart, valueless because it produces no true holiness, and powerless because it does not free from sin’s dominion. In this framework, whatever transformation occurs after faith is understood as the result of a believer’s voluntary effort rather than the inevitable fruit of God’s Spirit at work in the repentant believer (Phil 2:12–13). This shifts the decisive cause of holiness from God’s sovereign work to human will. The gospel becomes reduced to a legal transaction that secures a heavenly future but may leave the present life untouched. Scripture, however, portrays grace as saving “completely” (Heb 7:25, NIV)—not only pardoning sin but breaking its power and producing new obedience.[27] Grace that does not transform is not the biblical grace of Christ; it is a diminished substitute that promises the benefits of salvation without delivering the reality. 4.4. Recap Separating faith from repentance creates a theological system that: 1. Misrepresents biblical faith as purely cognitive. 2. Generates false assurance divorced from life transformation. 3. Makes grace powerless to transform lives. Faith and repentance are two sides of the same coin. Faith, while entirely a gift of God’s grace, always results in a life reoriented toward God. Assurance, therefore, is not abstract but observable in the life of the believer, creating both confidence and spiritual accountability. 5. Answering Common FGT Objections While FGT affirms salvation by grace through faith alone, it often resists identifying repentance as an essential aspect of saving faith. Below are common objections and biblical responses. 5.1. Faith alone is the sole requirement for eternal life, and adding repentance makes the gospel a works-based message. FGT insists that requiring repentance as part of the gospel undermines the freeness of grace. They define repentance as a human work incompatible with salvation by grace alone through faith alone. Response: Biblical repentance is not a meritorious work that earns salvation—it is the God-enabled turning of the heart toward Christ in faith. Scripture never presents repentance as something added to faith but as an inseparable aspect of saving faith itself (Acts 20:21; 26:20). Repentance is not about earning God’s favor; it is the Spirit’s gift that accompanies genuine trust in Christ, expressing itself in a turning from sin to God (Acts 11:18; 2 Tim. 2:25–26). To divorce repentance from faith is to redefine both terms in ways foreign to the apostolic gospel. 5.2. Repentance means only a change of mind, not turning from sin. Repentance is merely a change of mind. FGT teaches that metanoia in the New Testament refers to an intellectual acknowledgment of Christ or agreement with the gospel, not a turning from sin. Eternal life depends solely on faith in Christ, and any ethical or behavioral reorientation is considered a separate issue, relevant to discipleship. Response: In the New Testament, metanoia carries more than the sense of a mere change of mind. It describes a reorientation of life toward God and away from sin. Genuine saving faith always includes this turning—trusting Christ is inseparable from turning from sin. Repentance is not an optional add-on or a later stage of discipleship; it is part of what it means to truly believe. 5.3. The Gospel of John, written to bring people to faith, never mentions repentance. FGT appeals to John’s Gospel as the model evangelistic book, noting that it calls people to “believe” nearly 100 times but never once commands them to repent. They conclude that repentance is unnecessary for eternal life. Response: John’s emphasis on believing does not exclude the reality of repentance—it assumes it.[28] Belief, as John presents it, is never mere mental assent but a wholehearted trust that involves coming to the light and abandoning darkness (John 3:19–21). Jesus’ call to be “born again” (John 3:3) entails a radical transformation, which in other biblical contexts is described as repentance. When the Samaritan woman believed, she left her life of sin (John 4:28–29); the healed paralytic is told to “sin no more” (John 5:14); when the man born blind believed, he confessed Christ publicly (John 9:38). Jesus says “Whoever loves his life loses it, and whoever hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life. If anyone serves me, he must follow me…” (John 12:25-26). Jesus essentially says eternal life is connected with change of loves. Love for Jesus replaces love for self. The absence of the explicit term “repentance” does not indicate absence of its reality, just as the absence of the term “faith” in some evangelistic sermons (e.g., Acts 17:30–31) does not remove the necessity of faith. We must not build our doctrine on an argument from silence in a single book but on the plenary teaching of Scripture, which consistently unites repentance and faith in the gospel call (e.g. Luke 24:46–47; Acts 2:38; 17:30–31).[29] 5.4. Calling unbelievers to repent confuses the gospel with discipleship. FGT holds that repentance belongs to the realm of following Jesus after conversion, not to the initial reception of eternal life. They argue that including repentance in the gospel call burdens unbelievers with discipleship demands before they are even saved. Response: Jesus and the apostles made no such separation in their preaching. Christ began his ministry with “Repent and believe in the gospel” (Mark 1:15) and told would-be followers to count the cost (Luke 14:25–33). Peter’s Pentecost sermon to unbelievers included the command to “repent” for the forgiveness of sins (Acts 2:38). The call to turn from sin and self to God in Christ is not an advanced stage of Christian growth—it is the very essence of initial saving faith. Discipleship begins at conversion. 5.5. Linking repentance to faith front-loads the gospel. FGT fears requiring repentance will cause people to think they must reform their life before believing. Response: Biblical repentance is not self-reformation prior to faith; it is the faith-response itself. A sinner does not first make himself worthy—he turns to Christ in the very act of trusting him to save. The prodigal son “came to himself” and returned to the father as he was (Luke 15:17–20). Repentance is not cleaning oneself up to be accepted but fleeing to the only one who can cleanse. 5.6. Repentance is good and necessary but separate from the call to faith. FGT teaches that all people ought to repent, but they restrict repentance to a post-conversion or discipleship category. In their view, repentance relates to fellowship with God, spiritual growth, or avoiding temporal discipline—not to receiving eternal life. The gospel call to unbelievers, they argue, is solely to believe in Jesus for everlasting life, without reference to turning from sin. Response: The apostolic preaching unites repentance and faith in the same gospel call. Paul testified that he proclaimed to “both Jews and Greeks… repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ” (Acts 20:21). Likewise, when addressing unbelievers, he declared that God “commands all people everywhere to repent” in view of the coming judgment (Acts 17:30–31). The New Testament does not present repentance as an optional follow-up to belief but as the heart-orientation of turning to Christ in faith. By separating repentance from the gospel, FGT allows for people to be saved who never repent of their sin. 5.7. Assurance comes only from Christ’s promise, not from fruit. FGT insists that examining works for assurance undermines confidence in Christ alone. Response: Scripture grounds assurance both in Christ’s finished work (objective) and in the Spirit’s fruit in the believer’s life (subjective). John writes, “By this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments” (1 John 2:3). The Apostle Paul tells us that we are to “work out your own salvation with fear and trembling” (Phil 2:12).[30] Also, Christians are called to “Examine yourselves, to see whether you are in the faith” (2 Cor 14:5). This is not shifting trust to works but recognizing the Spirit’s transforming presence as evidence of genuine faith. 5.8. Repentance as Part of Salvation Encourages Judgmentalism Tying repentance to salvation risks making Christians judgmental, constantly evaluating whether others are truly saved based on their behavior. This could undermine assurance and make salvation appear dependent on works rather than Christ’s promise of eternal life by faith alone. Response: It is true that Scripture warns against hypocritical judgment with a condemning spirit. Jesus says, “Judge not, that you be not judged” (Matt 7:1). Yet in context, he calls us to remove the log from our own eye “then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye” (Matt 7:5). Far from banning all judgment, Jesus commands a righteous kind of judgment that is humble, self-aware, and restorative. Likewise, Paul writes, “For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge? God judges those outside” (1 Cor 5:12–13). Repentance plays a key role in this discernment: it is not the ground of salvation, but the fruit of genuine faith. To affirm a profession of faith while ignoring a lifestyle of unrepentance is to confuse grace with license. True grace produces repentance and obedience as its fruit (Titus 2:11–12). Therefore, requiring repentance does not foster judgmentalism but ensures that the church exercises righteous judgment, safeguards its witness, and lovingly affirms the integrity of genuine faith. 6. Defense of Orthodox Free Grace[31] 6.1. Salvation Is Free, Yet Transformative Historic Christianity affirms that salvation is entirely by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone (Eph 2:8–9). This grace is undeserved, unmerited, and freely given by God. However, the grace that saves is never alone. Rather, it transforms the believer, producing repentance, obedience, and sanctification. Titus 2:11–14 states: For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, training us to renounce ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age, waiting for our blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works. Here, grace is described as active and instructive, not passive. God’s gift of salvation is accompanied by training, purifying, and motivating the believer toward holiness. Orthodox soteriology recognizes that faith necessarily includes a turning away from sin and toward God—a turning that is both inward (repentance of heart) and outward (obedience in life). 6.2. Faith and Repentance Are Two Sides of the Same Coin As established in the Biblical Evidence section, passages such as Mark 1:15, Acts 20:21, James 2:14–26, and 1 John 2:3–6 consistently link faith and repentance. 6.3. Biblical and Pastoral Implications 1. Faith and Repentance Are Evidential — Assurance is grounded in God’s promises and confirmed by evidence in the believer’s life (1 John 2:3–6). 2. Transformative Grace Guards Against Legalism and Complacency — Grace is free, but it calls believers to action. It is neither coercive nor passive; it produces repentance and obedience naturally. 3. Pastoral Responsibility — Pastors must encourage both assurance and obedience. FGT’s model risks neglecting the pastoral call to nurture life transformation alongside the free gift of salvation.[32] By maintaining both the freeness of grace and its transformative power, the historic church preserves the biblical gospel in its fullness, while offering true, sustainable assurance to believers. 6.4. Recap Historic soteriology can be summarized as follows: 1. Salvation is free — entirely a work of God’s grace through faith. 2. Faith is always transformative — producing repentance, obedience, and good works. 3. Assurance is rooted in God’s promises and evident in the believer’s life — not in a mere intellectual or historical act of belief. This stands in contrast to FGT, which emphasizes freeness while minimizing the transformative aspects of faith. By integrating both biblical truth and historic orthodoxy, the Christian church safeguards the integrity of the gospel, ensuring that salvation is free, yet never cheap. 7. Pastoral Applications The theological distinctions between FGT and historic orthodoxy have significant implications for pastoral ministry, discipleship, and Christian formation. Understanding these implications ensures that believers are both assured and accountable, reflecting the fullness of God’s grace. 7.1. Preaching the Gospel Pastors must proclaim the gospel in a way that emphasizes both the freeness of salvation and the necessity of faith that transforms. While FGT stresses freeness, historic orthodoxy maintains that true faith cannot exist apart from repentance and life transformation (Mark 1:15; Acts 20:21). Preaching should invite listeners to trust Christ fully, while also turning from sin, illustrating that God’s grace is both free and active. 7.2. Encouraging True Assurance Assurance of salvation is central to the believer’s confidence and spiritual growth. True assurance rests not on a single intellectual act but on God’s promises confirmed in a life of faith and obedience (1 John 2:3–6). Pastors should help believers evaluate their faith by examining evidence of transformation, guiding them away from the false security promoted by FGT. 7.3. Discipleship and Spiritual Formation Discipleship involves nurturing faith that bears fruit. By emphasizing the inseparability of faith and repentance, pastors can cultivate spiritual disciplines, obedience, and holiness. This ensures that grace leads to lifelong growth, not complacency or moral stagnation. 7.4. Evangelism and Clarity Evangelism must convey that salvation is wholly by grace while calling for repentance and trust in Christ. Misrepresenting faith as mere belief, as FGT sometimes does, can lead to confusion or superficial conversions. Historical orthodoxy ensures that the gospel call invites both trust and transformation. 8. Conclusion FGT is a recent reinterpretation of salvation, separating faith from repentance and emphasizing assurance based solely on intellectual belief. While its proponents adopt the language of “free grace,” their theology departs from the historic teaching of the Christian church and the consistent witness of Scripture. The Bible clearly presents faith and repentance as inseparable, with genuine faith producing life transformation, obedience, and evidence of God’s work in the believer’s life (Mark 1:15; Acts 20:21; James 2:14–26; 1 John 2:3–6). Historic orthodoxy affirms that salvation is truly free, yet it is never inactive. God’s grace brings life change, calling believers to turn from sin, trust Christ fully, and bear fruit in obedience. For the pastor, teacher, and church leader, this understanding provides a foundation for preaching, discipleship, and pastoral care that protects believers from false assurance while nurturing a deep, transformative relationship with Christ. God’s grace is free, but it is also powerful—transforming hearts, producing holiness, and securing eternal life. As the church proclaims the gospel faithfully, it must hold in tension the freeness of grace and the necessity of faith that works through love, ensuring that believers are secure, transformed, and growing in Christ.Download this article Footnotes [1] Free Grace Theology will be referred to as FGT for the rest of this paper. [2] Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians, Ch.7, https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1010.htm, accessed 08/18/2025. [3] Ignatius of Antioch, The Epistle of Ignatius to the Smyrnaeans, Ch.5, https://www.catholica.com/epistle-of-ignatius-to-the-smyrnaeans/index.html, accessed 08/18/2025. [4] Justin Martyr, First Apology, Ch.16, https://biblehub.com/library/richardson/early_christian_fathers/the_first_apology_of_justin.htm, accessed 08/18/2025. [5] Tertullian, On Repentance, Ch.9, https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0320.htm, accessed 08/18/2025. [6] Gregory the Great, The Book of Pastoral Rule, III.30, Admonition 31. https://ia902307.us.archive.org/13/items/Elijah_Elisha/St.%20Gregory%20the%20Great%20-%20The%20Book%20of%20the%20Pastoral%20Rule.pdfaccessed 08/18/2025. [7] Martin Luther, Commentary on Galatians (Grand Rapids: Kregel Classics, 1979) 314. [8] Westminster Confession of Faith, Ch. 11, Sec. 2. [9] London Baptist Confession (1689), Ch. 16, Sec. 2. [10] John Wesley, Sermon 35,https://wesley.nnu.edu/john-wesley/the-sermons-of-john-wesley-1872-edition/sermon-35-the-law-established-through-faith-discourse-one/ accessed 08/18/2025. [11] Billy Graham, “Wit & Wisdom: Grace of God,” 12/09/2015, https://billygrahamlibrary.org/wit-wisdom-grace-of-god/ accessed 8/13/2025. Some FGT may argue that this a Calvinist understanding of salvation. Billy Graham is listed here because he was not Calvinist to illustrate that this is the understanding of Evangelical theology. [12] Zane C. Hodges, Absolutely Free! A Biblical Reply to Lordship Salvation (Dallas: Redencion Viva, 1989). [13] See also Wayne A. Grudem, “Free Grace” Theology: 5 Ways It Diminishes the Gospel (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2016). Michael Horton, Christless Christianity: The Alternative Gospel of the American Church (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2008). R. C. Sproul, Faith Alone: The Evangelical Doctrine of Justification (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1995). Thomas R. Schreiner and Ardel B. Caneday, The Race Set Before Us: A Biblical Theology of Perseverance and Assurance (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2001). [14] See Athanasius, On the Incarnation, §5, 9. Augustine, On the Grace of Christ and Original Sin, I.24. Leo the Great, Letter to the Bishop of Aquileia (Letter 1), II.3. [15] All Scripture references are from the ESV unless otherwise stated. Mark 1:15 is representative of other passages in the gospel where Jesus links faith and repentance together. See also: Matt 4:7; Luke 5:32; 11:32; 13:3; 15:3-7, 8-10; 17:34; 24:46-47. [16] According to BDAG (the gold-standard academic Greek lexicon), there are two definitions given for metanoia. The first is “change of mind,” but there are no biblical uses mentioned. The second definition is “feel remorse, repent, be converted.” There are numerous New Testament uses of metanoia fitting this definition attested to. S.v. “μετανοέω,” Arndt, William, Frederick W. Danker, Walter Bauer, and F. Wilbur Gingrich. in A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000. [17] See above James 2:19-20. [18] In Romans 1:17, the phrase “from faith for faith” can be translated as “beginning and ending in faith,” see the footnote in the ESV version. The NIV renders this as “by faith from first to last.” [19] Thomas Schreiner, Faith Alone—The Doctrine of Justification: What the Reformers Taught … and Why It Still Matters (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2015), 23. [20] Zane Hodges, Absolutely Free: A Biblical Reply to Lordship Salvation, 2nd ed. (Corinth, TX: Grace Evangelical Society, 1989, 2014) 101. [21] Bob Nyberg, “A History of Free Grace,” (2021), https://www.gracelife.org/resources/grr/?id=31, accessed 08/18/2025. [22] Those who profess faith. [23] Bob Wilkin and Ken Yates, “If You Throw Away or Abandon Your Faith, How Can You Still Be Saved?” 2/7/2023, https://faithalone.org/radio/if-you-throw-away-or-abandon-your-faith-how-can-you-still-be-saved/, accessed 8/14/2025. [24] FGT proponents would also say that such people ought to repent and live for the Lord so that they have eternal rewards in heaven. However, the error here is still grave. [25] There are plenty of Scriptures that warn that those who practice such things will not inherit the Kingdom. See 1 Cor 6:9-10; Gal 5:19-21; Eph 5:5. [26] Hodges, Absolutely Free, 82. [27] The word in Hebrews 7:25 translated as “completely” in the NIV, is translated as “to the uttermost” in the ESV, and “forever” in the NASB. All these senses are carried by the Greek word in this passage. Therefore, to save completely and forever is in view here which has implications for the life of the saved person here and now. For more on this see: David L. Allen, Hebrews, NAC (Nashville: B & H Publishing Group, 2010), 429, and Thomas R. Schreiner, Hebrews, EBTC (Bellingham: Lexham Press, 2021), 233. [28] I am appreciative of Wayne Grudem’s insights here. See Wayne A. Grudem, “Free Grace” Theology: 5 Ways It Diminishes the Gospel (Wheaton: Crossway, 2016), 48-54. [29] Similarly, possibly the most evangelistic book, the book of Acts, never mentions the love of God. If a theology for evangelism were derived strictly from Acts (ignoring the rest of Scripture), then the conclusion (using the logic above with reference to repentance and John’s gospel) would be that the love of God has no part in evangelism. This is further evidence that we must have the whole counsel of God (Acts 20:27). [30] The gospel beauty of this is found in the following verse “for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Phil 2:13). This means that part of our salvation is to work out what God has worked in. In other words, even our works are God ordained responses to God, but this passage implies that these responses accompany a saving faith. [31] Orthodox is in reference to “right doctrine.” This is not a reference to the Greek or Russian Orthodox Church. [32] A salvation that is separated from the process of being conformed into the image of Christ essentially severs justification from sanctification. In other words, sanctification becomes a second type salvation (or at least a second tier salvation). If salvation is merely about going to heaven, then it begs the question: How is this eternal life? Jesus said “this is eternal life, that they know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent” (John 17:3). If eternal life is about knowing the triune God, and knowing him is to be in relationship with him, then how can there be salvation for those who do not walk with him? Such a gospel is both a powerless gospel (because it affects no change) and a Christ-less gospel (because there is no relationship with Christ).
April 16, 2025 • 28 Minute Read
Mutual Membership
The elders would like to propose in this paper that part of what makes up a local church is the mutual agreement of members to be organized as a church. The elders would like the members to consider changing the way we receive new members and remove members from the local church. Currently, this is a decision made entirely by the elders, but we believe we would be more faithful to Scripture if the congregation was involved. On Sunday, January 25, 1880, what is now called Solid Rock Christian Fellowship (then Lone Star Baptist Church) held its first service. The minutes taken on that day read “On Sunday January 25th, 1880, the following brethren and sisters met together for the purpose of organizing themselves into a church…” Did you catch that? On January 24th there was no church and on January 25th there was a church. So, what happened that there was a church formed on that Sunday? What Is a Local Church? In order to answer that question, we must take a moment to ask the question: what is a local church? Is it just any group of Christians who gather together? If that is so, then a group of Christians in a pickleball club could classify as a church. Is it having a non-profit 501(c)3 status? If that is the case a Christian non-profit organization could be considered a church. Is it having a religious building? In England I have seen many church buildings converted into apartments and mosques. Besides, when this church was organized, it met in a schoolhouse on Miller Valley Ranch (similar to many church plants today). Some Definitions with a Common Thread There are several things that make up a church, but one of them is the commitment we make to one another as members of a church. This is why many churches implement a church covenant so that what is implicitly expected of the members of a church is helpfully made explicit. Looking at various documents of Baptists since the reformation show this agreement. 1644 London Baptist Confession That Christ has here on earth a spiritual Kingdom, which is the Church, which He has purchased and redeemed to Himself, as a particular inheritance: which Church, as it is visible to us, is a company of visible saints, called and separated from the world, by the Word and the Spirit of God, to the visible profession of the faith of the Gospel, being baptized into the faith, and joined to the Lord, and each other, by mutual agreement, in the practical enjoyment of the ordinances, commanded by Christ their head and King.[1] Notice some of the threads highlighted here: 1. they are separated from the world; 2. they are visible saints; 3. the Word and Spirit are at work; 4. they believe the gospel; 5. there is mutual agreement; 6. baptism and the Lord’s supper are administered; 7. they are joined to the Lord and each other. This last one is of particular interest for our question at hand. They are joined together by mutual agreement. This is the idea underlying a covenant of fellowship. It is an intentional agreement between members, who make up a church. We see examples of this in other documents from Protestant history, specifically in the Baptist tradition. 1689 London Baptist Confession The members of these churches are saints by calling, visibly manifesting and evidencing (in and by their profession and walking) their obedience unto that call of Christ; and do willingly consent to walk together, according to the appointment of Christ; giving up themselves to the Lord, and one to another, by the will of God, in professed subjection to the ordinances of the Gospel.[2] In this confession, they “do willingly consent to walk together” and “giving up themselves to the Lord, and one to another.” This carries the same basic meaning as the phrase “by mutual agreement” above. 1833 New Hampshire Confession of Faith We believe that a visible church of Christ is a congregation of baptized believers, associated by covenant in the faith and fellowship of the gospel; observing the ordinances of Christ; governed by his laws; and exercising the gifts, rights, and privileges invested in them by his word; that its only scriptural officers are bishops or pastors and deacons whose qualifications, claims and duties are defined in the Epistles to Timothy and Titus.[3] This is the confession of faith our church adopted at its inception in 1880. But notice the similar clause “associated by covenant in the faith and fellowship of the gospel.” The same sense of mutual agreement is expressed here also. 2000 Baptist Faith and Message A New Testament church of the Lord Jesus Christ is an autonomous local congregation of baptized believers, associated by covenant in the faith and fellowship of the gospel; observing the two ordinances of Christ, governed by His laws, exercising the gifts, rights, and privileges invested in them by His Word, and seeking to extend the gospel to the ends of the earth. Each congregation operates under the Lordship of Christ through democratic processes. In such a congregation each member is responsible and accountable to Christ as Lord. Its two scriptural offices are that of pastor/elder/overseer and deacon. While both men and women are gifted for service in the church, the office of pastor / elder / overseer is limited to men as qualified by Scripture. The New Testament speaks also of the church as the Body of Christ which includes all of the redeemed of all the ages, believers from every tribe, and tongue, and people, and nation.[4] This is the confessional document of the Southern Baptist Convention. While we are not in the SBC it illustrates a historic consistency. The SBC used the clause in the New Hampshire Confession of Faith word for word: “associated by covenant in the faith and fellowship of the gospel.” Mutual Agreement In each of these documents, it is instructive that one of the elements that constitute a church is a mutual agreement of the members, or for the sake of the title of this paper, there is a mutual membership. Ultimately, there is a recognized group (membership) that constitutes being part of a local church. This is why we practice regenerate church membership. That is to say, that only those who are made alive by the Spirit (regenerated) can become members of a church. As these people mutually agree together in being part of a local church, they can then grow together. But how do we mutually agree? How is a person brought into church membership (with agreement) and how is a person removed from church membership (with agreement)? To understand this, we need to look directly at some biblical texts. The Keys of the Kingdom The above discussion about confessional statements is helpful in framing the kind of question we should be asking ourselves, but the answer ultimately comes down to what the Scriptures teach and secondly how we walk in the things taught by Scripture. Regarding the issue of voting in and out members, Matthew 16:13-19; 18:15-20; 28:18-20 and 1 Corinthians 5 speak with clarity. Any discussion about the question of people becoming part of a local church or leaving (or being removed from) a local church must consider these passages. To ignore them would be to ignore some of the most relevant passages on this question. Matthew 16:13-19 Jesus asks his disciples “Who do you say I am?” (Matt 16:15). Peter, by the work of the Spirit, replies “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God” (Matt 16:16-17). Jesus then follows up Peter’s confession with those monumental words: “And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it” (Matt 16:18).5 This is the first use of “church” in the New Testament, which tells us it is significant! It is doubly significant because Jesus says he will build his church. If we want to understand how he builds his church, we have to look at this passage. Jesus Builds His Church Jesus then goes on to explain how he will build his church. What he says can sound cryptic or confusing. Jesus tells Peter, “I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matt 20:19, italics added). This passage has been wildly misinterpreted over the years as some spectrums of the Christian church seek to bind and loose things left and right. But context is king. We must ask: What are the keys? What is being bound? What is being loosed? The Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven Keys speak to authority and stewardship. It is kind of like when a teenager says, “Dad gave me the keys to the car.” There is an authority to drive the car implicit in the giving of the keys, and there is a responsibility as a driver. A better analogy would be to view a local church like an embassy of the Kingdom of Heaven. Over the twenty years, our family lived in Europe, we often had to go to the U.S. Embassy. Whether that embassy was in Vienna or London, we would have to go there in order to issue new passports, get birth certificates or any business that pertained to our dealings with our role as U.S. citizens living abroad. When one of our children were born, we would stand in front of the consular general, show documentation for our newborn, and swear before the consular general that the child was indeed our child. At that point, the consular general exercised the “keys” of the kingdom of the United States and issued us a “Consular Report of Birth Abroad” (a fancy name for a birth certificate). The consular general is a U.S. citizen, but as a citizen, he did not have the authority to issue our child a birth certificate or passport. If we encountered the consular general in a Viennese coffee shop, he had no authority. The authority was connected to the embassy. In other words, in the embassy, he speaks and acts with the kingdom’s authority. The local church is the embassy of the Kingdom of heaven, and we are the ambassadors of the Kingdom. As a local church we function in this world as an outpost (or embassy) of heaven. We are heaven’s citizens, and as the church we hold the keys of the Kingdom. Binding and Loosing So, what does it mean that we bind and loose? This is the function of keys. They unlock doors and they lock doors. Holding the keys of the Kingdom, we have a delegated authority from the King. We have authority to take a heavenly reality and make it binding on earth. The consular general who issues the passport (or denies the passport) as a function of the keys of an earthly government, is binding and loosing. The reality of citizenship is affirmed by the issuing of the passport. It is clear that we, as a church, have the Kingdom keys to take what is true in heaven and pronounce that truth on earth (binding and loosing). But what is being bound and what is being loosed? To explain this, we must look at the very next time Jesus uses the words bind, loose, and church. Matthew 18:15-20 The Three-fold Process of Church Discipline This is a well-known passage in dealing with issues of sin in the church, “If your brother sins against you…” (Matt 18:15). Jesus lays out a pathway for dealing with sin in the church. Jesus lays out a three-step process for this. Step 1. Go to the brother (or sister) who has sinned one to one. (Matt 18:15). Step 2. If he does not listen then take one or two others with you (two or three to one, Matt 18:16). Step 3. If he still will not listen then take it before the church (the church to one, Matt 18:17). This is a process. This does not mean step one on Monday, step two on Tuesday, etc. We are to be patient and loving in our implementation of these steps. The goal is not to check the boxes, but to work toward restoration. Jesus first used the word “church” in Matthew 16:13-19, and he associated it with “binding and loosing.” Therefore, it is significant that the only other time Jesus uses the word “church” in all the Gospels is two chapters later (Matt 18:17). It is also significant that he speaks of the church in terms of binding and loosing (Matt 18:18). The gospel of Matthew intends for us to connect the church with the function of binding and loosing. Binding and Loosing Clarified Matthew 16 left us with a question as to what was meant by binding and loosing. That the church has the keys to bind and loose was clear, but it is not until Matthew 18 that the actual work of binding and loosing is given clarity. The context here is after the third step of church discipline where the matter is brought before the church—if a person persists in his sin, the church is to treat him as a Gentile and a tax collector—an unbeliever (Matt 18:17). That means that when the person is brought before the church (not just some members of the church, that’s step two), the church makes a pronouncement which in essence is “Because you are persisting in unrepentant sin, we cannot affirm your profession of faith.” That is what it means to treat him as a Gentile or tax collector. That pronouncement, Jesus says, is an act of binding and loosing “whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven” (Matt 18:18, italics added). No matter how small the church is, this is an act of agreement by it. This is why Jesus says, “if two of you agree” (Matt 18:19). A church requires at least two believers in agreement. The oft quoted verse “For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I among them” (Matt 18:20) is a verse speaking about the church exercising Kingdom authority in church discipline. To be clear, it is the church that removes somebody from membership not individuals. Like the consular general in the Viennese coffee shop, there is no authority there—the authority rests in the embassy. Our authority rests in the church, the gathered members conducting the business of the Kingdom. Matthew 28:18-20 A Delegated Authority The Great Commission reveals the delegated authority given to the church. Jesus declares, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go, therefore, and make disciples…” (Matt 28:18-19a). Jesus possesses all authority and entrusts the church with this authority. In Matthew 16 and 18, Jesus affirms that whatever the church binds on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever it looses on earth will be loosed in heaven. This reinforces the principle that all authority ultimately belongs to Jesus, who delegates it to the church. This delegation forms the foundation for binding and loosing—demonstrating that the church operates under Christ’s authority. As the embassy of heaven, we function with the authority of the Kingdom for the glory of the King! This delegated authority is exercised through making disciples, baptizing, and teaching (Matt 28:19-20). Discipleship begins with conversion, baptism serves as the recognition of Kingdom citizenship (akin to an embassy issuing a passport), and teaching instructs citizens on how life in the Kingdom operates. In this mission, Jesus assures, “I am with you” (Matt 28:20), echoing his promise in Matthew 18:20: “Where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them.” Thus, the Great Commission not only establishes the church’s authority but also affirms Christ’s continual presence in that authority. 1 Corinthians 5 A First Century Church Exercising the Keys Paul’s two letters to the Corinthians offer profound insight into how a church should function. In 1 Corinthians 5, Paul addresses a case of unrepentant sin within the congregation. A man, claiming to be a believer, is persisting in sin. But the church thinks it gracious to overlook his actions and fails to address the issue. Paul corrects this approach, instructing, “Let him who has done this be removed from among you” (1 Cor 5:2). Because this man continues in sin, he should no longer be considered part of the believing community. Paul emphasizes that this action is to be taken when the church is assembled “in the name of the Lord Jesus”—that is, under Christ’s delegated authority (1 Cor 5:4). At first, this directive may not seem pastoral or gracious, but in reality, it is both! Paul explains, “You are to deliver this man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord” (1 Cor 5:5). In other words, by formally removing him from church membership, the congregation signals that his life is not in line with his profession of faith. He no longer enjoys the spiritual protection of church fellowship. The hope is that this severe measure will awaken him to repentance. This is the final step in the Matthew 18 process, meant to make clear that he is deceiving himself by continuing in sin. Since this decision is made corporately (1 Cor 5:4), the church body is aware of the situation. Members can pray for the individual and call him to repentance. Unchecked sin is a threat to the entire church— “A little leaven leavens the whole lump” (1 Cor 5:6). The church must be cleansed of persistent, unrepentant sin because Christ died to make His people holy (1 Cor 5:7). Thus, removing the unrepentant sinner serves to first, protect the church, second to prevent the sinner from a false assurance of salvation, third to protect Christ’s witness in the community, and forth to strengthen the members (more on this below). Paul instructs that this individual should not be treated as a brother in Christ (1 Cor 5:9-11). Jesus similarly commands that such a person be regarded “as a Gentile and a tax collector” (Matt 18:17). This does not mean shunning him but rather interacting with him in a way that lovingly calls him to repentance—just as we would with any unbeliever. Some may object that such action seems judgmental, but this is precisely the church’s responsibility! Paul clarifies, “For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge?” (1 Cor 5:12). As ambassadors of heaven, entrusted with Christ’s authority to bind and loose, the church is called to exercise righteous judgment in matters of discipline, always aiming for restoration and the glory of God. We Are Called to This This is not something to be done individually—it is the responsibility of the church as a whole. That is why Matthew 18:17 instructs bringing the matter before the church and why 1 Corinthians 5:4 emphasizes acting as an assembled body. This principle applies both to welcoming new members and to removing members. Together, the congregation affirms those who join and those who depart. Some may leave because they have moved on to another faithful church, while others may be removed through formal church discipline. Understanding Church Discipline What Church Discipline Does When I speak of church discipline in this context, I am referring specifically to formal church discipline, where a serious issue is brought before the church. In a broader sense, church discipline includes any formative or corrective engagement that encourages one another’s growth in Christ. We practice discipline whenever we instruct, correct, rebuke, or train one another in righteousness (2 Tim 3:16). However, here we are focusing on formal church discipline. Church discipline serves four primary purposes, all aimed at the spiritual well-being of those involved: protecting the church, protecting the church’s witness, removing the church’s protection, and strengthening the members. Protecting the Church When your body has an infection, it is crucial to treat it—left unchecked, it will cause greater harm. In the same way, church discipline seeks to remove spiritual infection for the health of the body. As Paul said, “a little leaven leavens the whole lump” (1 Cor 5:6). To guard the church from participating in and being affected by the presence of sin, church discipline seeks the holiness of the church. Protecting the Church’s Witness When a church tolerates open sin among its members, it damages its testimony to the world. For example, if a member—let’s call him Rupert—is known to be engaging in extramarital sex while remaining in good standing within the church, the church’s credibility is compromised. This was precisely the situation in 1 Corinthians 5:1. The watching world sees such hypocrisy and concludes that the church is no different from the rest of society. Some will (rightly) accuse the church of hypocrisy, preaching one thing but practicing another. By addressing unrepentant sin, church discipline upholds the church’s witness and maintains the integrity of its message. Removing the Church’s Protection When the church disciplines an unrepentant sinner, it is removing the spiritual protection that comes with being part of the church. This action is not punitive but redemptive—it is meant to call the individual to repentance (Matt 18:15-17). Being part of the church provides encouragement, accountability, and the assurance that comes with walking in fellowship with other believers. However, when someone persists in sin without repentance, remaining in the church can lead to false assurance of faith (1 John 1:5; 2:19). By removing them from membership, the church signals that the individual’s life is not bearing the marks of true repentance and saving faith. Additionally, removal allows the natural consequences of sin to lead the person to repentance, much like the story of the prodigal son (Luke 15:11-32). In that parable, the son only recognized his need for the father after experiencing the emptiness and hardship of his rebellion. Likewise, church discipline aims to bring the unrepentant to the realization that life apart from Christ and his people is empty and destructive, leading them to return in genuine repentance. Strengthening the Members At first, this may seem like a surprising outcome of church discipline. However, this is not about wielding authority in a domineering way—it is about cultivating sobriety and responsibility among church members. Before the church acts, each member must first examine their own heart (Matt 7:1- 6). Church discipline is not an opportunity for self-righteousness but a call to humility. It reminds believers that they, too, must walk in repentance and grace. Additionally, church discipline places on the members the responsibility of restoration. Rather than simply casting someone out, those who know the individual are encouraged to pursue reconciliation. As James 5:19-20 says, “My brothers, if anyone among you wanders from the truth and someone brings him back, let him know that whoever brings back a sinner from his wandering will save his soul from death and will cover a multitude of sins.” Church membership is not just about personal faith—it is about mutual holiness and joy in Christ. Through discipline, the church collectively commits to guarding one another’s walk with the Lord, ensuring that no one drifts away unnoticed or unloved. When Church Discipline Is Used However, not every issue warrants formal discipline. For church discipline to be appropriate, the matter must be biblical, outward, significant, and unrepentant. Biblical The issue must be one clearly addressed in Scripture, not merely a matter of personal conviction. For example, drunkenness is a biblical sin, whereas drinking a glass of wine falls under Christian liberty. Church discipline should never be used to impose personal preferences or convictions as if they were biblical commands. I once heard of a church excommunicating a seventeen-year-old for attending a high school dance. In such a case, discipline was misapplied, as the church was binding the person’s conscience to something Scripture does not forbid. Outward The sin must be provable, supported by clear evidence or reliable witnesses (Matt 18:16). Discipline should never be based on hearsay or speculation. Ensuring that accusations are outward prevents arbitrary or unjust discipline. For example, greed is primarily an inward sin, making it difficult to discipline someone for it directly. How can you determine if a person is truly acting out of greed? However, if that greed manifests in clear, outward actions—such as embezzling church funds or exploiting others for financial gain—then formal church discipline becomes necessary. In such cases, the sin is no longer hidden but has tangible, harmful effects that must be addressed. Significant The offense should be serious enough to harm the reputation of Christ’s church or misrepresent the gospel. Not every sin requires formal discipline; wisdom and discernment are necessary to determine when an issue rises to this level. For example, if a brother tends to have a negative attitude, even though we are called to walk in confident hope, this may warrant a conversation between brothers. However, it would not be significant enough to require church discipline. Unrepentant The life of the Christian is centered on the gospel call to repentance. Unrepentant sin is an indication of a hardness to the gospel of Jesus. Unrepentance points to a lack of understanding of who Jesus is and what Jesus has done. This is different from a person who is weak and repentant but keeps stumbling. This is the person who stubbornly persists in his sin. The Scriptures are clear that formal church discipline is the responsibility of the whole church. The elders lead the way, but the church (that is: membership) does not sit on the sidelines. They have an important part in this process The Goal of Church Discipline The ultimate goal of church discipline is the restoration of the individual. A powerful example of this is found in 2 Corinthians 2:5-11, where someone who had been under church discipline in Corinth repented. This may even be the same man mentioned in 1 Corinthians 5! Upon his repentance, Paul exhorts the church to “turn to forgive and comfort him” (2 Cor 2:7) and “reaffirm your love for him” (2 Cor 2:8). This is a beautiful picture of what church discipline is meant to accomplish—not punishment, but repentance, restoration, and renewed fellowship. A Real-Life Example I once attended a members' meeting at another church as a guest. During the meeting, the congregation voted to remove a man from membership due to unrepentant adultery. Later in that same meeting, something remarkable happened—a man was brought in who had been removed from membership three years earlier for the same sin and had repented. The elders and people in the church who knew him continued reaching out to him and praying for him. He stood before the congregation and read a heartfelt testimony of his repentance. Then, following the church’s process, he stepped out of the room while the members voted on his restoration to membership. When the vote was affirmed, he was brought back in—and the entire congregation stood in applause! Truly there is more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents (Luke 15:7)! This moment moved me to tears. The hard love of church discipline had served its God-given purpose. Members of the church had continued to pray for him, pursue him, and call him to repentance. These two cases—one man removed in sorrow, another restored in joy—beautifully demonstrated the heart behind church discipline: a commitment to holiness, love, and redemption. Bringing Members into the Church If the church exercises the keys in binding and loosing with regard to church discipline, then it only makes sense that the church also exercises the keys when bringing people into membership. Our Current Process Membership Classes When someone is interested in becoming a member, they participate in the membership classes (if you have not participated in one of these classes in the last three years, then we encourage you to do so). The classes are meant to give perspective members a good understanding of who we are as a church. Those classes cover six lessons. Declaration of Faith—Any perspective member has to know what we believe as a church and be in agreement with the church’s doctrine. Covenant of Fellowship—Members commit to the covenant of fellowship. Ours makes what is implicitly expected of members in a church and makes it explicit. Why Join a Church—Living out God’s intended purposes for his church requires commitment to one another through formal and meaningful membership. Church Leadership and Mission—This class explains how our church polity works and the importance of each of us to be engaged in the Great Commission. Church History—This class gives a very brief overview of church history and focuses on the history of Baptist churches and specifically the history of this church. Life Together—This class explains the dynamics of living in community together, including using our gifts and how we deal with relational conflicts. Elder Interview After completing the membership class and signing the Declaration of Faith and Covenant of Fellowship, the candidate meets with one or two elders for an interview. This meeting serves several purposes: To address any lingering questions the candidate may have. To provide an opportunity for personal interaction with an elder. To confirm that the candidate is not under church discipline at another church. To assess whether the candidate has truly experienced regeneration (conversion).[6] Elder Recommendation and Vote If the interviewing elder is confident that the candidate’s profession of faith is credible, he will present the individual’s application and testimony to the full body of elders for consideration. The elders review the relevant details and, if there are no concerns, they vote to affirm the new member. Our Recommended Changes Given the biblical principles outlined in this document, we affirm that elders should lead in the membership process, as they currently do. However, when it comes to the final decision of receiving or removing members, we believe the assembled members should vote, in accordance with the New Testament pattern. Removing Members The process of church discipline is carried out with care, patience, and conviction. If an individual remains unrepentant after due process, the elders will bring a recommendation for removal before the congregation at a member meeting. First Meeting: The elders present their recommendation, allowing time for those in the church who know the individual to personally call them to repentance. Second Meeting: If the individual remains unrepentant, the congregation will vote to remove them from membership. This process provides an opportunity for pastoral engagement and restoration while ensuring that church discipline is carried out with wisdom and grace. Receiving Members The elders will continue to carefully examine candidates for membership. However, instead of voting them in directly, the elders will recommend candidates to the congregation in advance of the member meeting. If any church member has biblical concerns about a candidate, they can discuss them privately with the elders before the vote.[7] If no concerns arise, the congregation will vote to receive the new member. Biblical and Historical Alignment This process is not new—it has historical precedent both in church history and in our own church’s past practice. By following this model, we more faithfully steward the biblical principles found in Matthew 16, 18, 28; 1 Corinthians 5; and 2 Corinthians 2. We will know the membership better. We will engage the membership with the responsibility we ought to feel for one another. We will be participating in membership that is meaningful and substantive. We will be exercising the delegated authority of the keys that Jesus commanded in a more faithful and clear way.Download this article Footnotes [1] 1644 London Baptist Confession, §33. [2] 1689 London Baptist Confession, §26.6. [3] 1833, New Hampshire Confession of Faith, §13. [4] 2000 Baptist Faith and Message, §6. [5] I will not try to answer the question as to whether the church is built on Peter or on his confession here. If it is Peter, it is still pointing to what Peter confessed, thus the outcome is the same. Jesus will build his church with those who profess by the Spirit that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the living God. [6] Many individuals in churches assume they are Christians without having truly been born again. This interview is one way the elders seek to ensure that membership is reserved for those who have been regenerated by the Holy Spirit. In some cases, these meetings take on an evangelistic nature, particularly when the candidate is a cultural Christian who may not yet understand the true gospel. [7] This also guards the church against gossip.
May 14, 2024 • 7 Minute Read
To What End - Part 2
Our country is wound tight when it comes to politics. In recent years, the left and right poles of the spectrum have caused the polls to become trench warfare. Common ground in the middle has become no man’s land. One of the effects this has had is that political views are voiced more and more forcefully about everything imaginable, even gas stoves! Positions are trending toward an all or nothing attitude. Nuance and discourse do not seem to be welcome dinner guests. Those who do not share a certain political vision are labeled, canceled, or villainized by the other side. Facts seem less important than outrage. In fact, outrage is the new black. I have personally experienced this in our own community. I have discovered things about myself that I never knew! If you believe the scuttlebutt, then I am pro-abortion and pro-LGBTQ+ (obviously those promoting this never knew that I was featured on the front page of a UK newspaper as pro-heterosexual). I have heard that I am the “woke pastor” of Prescott! Of course, none of this is true, but let’s not trifle with facts. All of this merely illustrates that we need a healthy way of approaching political issues with a level of theo-political triage. I would like to present a helpful tool that Robert Benne develops in his book Good and Bad Ways to Think About Politics and Religion (Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 2010). This was later discussed in Jonathan Leeman’s How the Nations Rage: Rethinking Faith and Politics in a Divided Age (Thomas Nelson, 2018). Benne and Leeman point out two kinds of issues: straight-line and jagged-line. We would be helped in learning how to approach our political vision in light of these tools. Straight-Line Issues Some issues are clear issues. These would be straight line issues. Abortion would be a straight line issue. The Bible says that people are the image of God at conception and that murder is wrong because it kills the image of God. A straight line issue is an issue where the Bible is clear about a certain issue. You can more or less draw a straight line from the text of Scripture to the issue in question. There are several issues that would fit this sort of straight line approach (e.g. human sexuality, marriage, sanctity of life issues, religious freedom, etc.). These types of issues, we can speak with unequivocal conviction. Every Christian ought to be in agreement with these issues because the Scriptures are clear concerning them. These are the kind of issues that are appropriate to take a stance on from a church pulpit. Why? Because the Bible is blatantly clear. But not every issue is so clear, which is why there is a jagged-line approach. Jagged-Line Issues A straight line from biblical text to an issue cannot always be drawn. These issues require wisdom and prudence in applying biblical texts that help clarify a view on the issue. A large majority of political issues will fall into this category. Some examples might be discussions regarding a minimum wage, healthcare, immigration, environment, education (although this may find its way to a straight-line issue when a policy would take education out of the hands of the parents and puts it into the hands of the state), etc. Just because an issue is a jagged-line issue, this does not mean that we should not come to a conviction on where we stand on a given issue. Rather it means that we hold that conviction generously. For example, we live in a border state and so immigration is an important topic. But what is the biblical approach to immigration? Two Christians may approach the issue in differing ways. Christian A: The Scriptures speak a lot about reaching the nations and so welcoming in the nations gives an opportunity to reach them. Israel welcomed the foreigners so that they could be a light to them. The Scripture calls us to care for those suffering and there are those coming into the country out of horrible living conditions or those looking for asylum from despotic regimes. Care for the world drives the desire for weaker borders. Christian B: Borders exist for a reason. We must take care of those we are in a social contract with, which is made up of citizens, and the influx of immigrants diminishes our ability to take care of those who would be a greater priority (family, then community, then nation, then world). Care for those of our own country drives the desire for stronger borders. The issue of immigration is much more complex than I have portrayed it above. But I want you to see that there is a process to coming to a conviction that should be built on biblical principles. Given that they are built on biblical principles, we should respect those who hold opposing views. I am not suggesting we should agree with those who hold opposing views. What I have seen too often is that the unity of the church is threatened by the way we hold our oppositions. What can happen is because we do not agree with a certain jagged-line stance, we begin to question the legitimacy of someone’s faith. When this happens, we determine whether or not someone is truly a Christian based on a political position or party affiliation. Straight-Line Issues and Policies We should all agree on the straight-line issues, but that doesn’t mean that we all share the same policies. Consider the straight-line issue on the sanctity of the unborn. What is the best policy to bring this about? There are some approaches that would be morally wrong. Should we blow up a Planned Parenthood clinic? No. That would go against other straight-line issues. Should we push for total abortion bans or seek a progressive approach to limit abortions to those below twelve weeks in the short run? Should we stand outside abortion clinics with graphic images of aborted children? Should we participate in a walk for life march? Should we write our representatives? Different people will end up in different places when it comes to approaches and policies to different issues. I would like to close with a short story of how politics almost split the church I planted in London. In 2016, the UK was preparing for a major vote called Brexit (whether Britain should exit the EU). This was a significant piece of legislation. The concern was that Britain had given up its autonomy to the European Union and withdrawal from the EU was put on the ballot. Over 50% of our church were internationals, many of whom were from the EU. Many Brits started showing up to church wearing “Leave” buttons on their coats. The message this gave to our internationals was “We don’t want you in our country anymore.” Of course, this was not the intention of those with the “Leave” buttons on their coats. They loved their international brothers and sisters-in-Christ. But if Brexit passed, many in our church would have to leave the country. Politics nearly destroyed our church. But I taught our church about straight-line and jagged-line issues. Brexit was an important issue, but it was a jagged-line issue. By God’s grace, love for the brethren prevailed. Although many in the church had radically divergent views on a significant jagged-line political issue, the unity of the Spirit was maintained to the glory of God. After all, we were all citizens of heaven. So my brothers and sisters, I pray this tool is helpful to you as you process your politics especially in this election year. If you’d like to read more on this topic, The Gospel Coalition website has a good summary article.Download this articleGo to part 3